Haryana woman waits 27 years for government job, gets appointed as teacher five months before retirement; was asked to join in 1999 but never received appointment letter

At 57, Jai Mala is set to become a Haryana government Sanskrit teacher with only five months left before retirement. The Punjab and Haryana High Court has ordered her appointment from June 10, 1999, with consequential benefits, after finding that ...

Haryana woman waits 27 years for a government job, gets appointed as teacher five months before retirement; was asked to join in 1999 but never received appointment letter.

Jai Mala, a 57-year-old woman from Haryana, is finally set to become a government Sanskrit teacher, 27 years after education authorities asked her to join a school in Rewari but never issued her formal appointment letter. With only five months left before her scheduled retirement in April, she has won a legal battle that began in 1999.

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has directed the state government to appoint her with effect from June 10, 1999, along with all consequential benefits. The court also set aside two earlier judgments that had rejected her claim.

Why did Jai Mala wait 27 years for her appointment letter?

According to a Times of India report, Jai Mala's struggle began in December 1998, when she was called for an interview for the post of Sanskrit teacher.


In June 1999, the district education officer scrutinised her educational certificates and asked her to join a government school in Rewari. However, the formal appointment letter never arrived.

Despite repeatedly approaching the authorities, she could not secure the letter. She eventually filed a lawsuit seeking appointment from June 10, 1999, along with arrears of salary, allowances and interest.

The prolonged dispute also affected her family. Her husband, Roop Chand, said the repeated disappointments and uncertainty took a toll on her physical and mental health. He said she suffered depression and a cardiac attack during the period.
ADVERTISEMENT

The couple also spent lakhs of rupees pursuing the case.

Why did Haryana government reject her teacher appointment?

The state government opposed her claim, arguing that she had not submitted a certificate establishing knowledge of Hindi up to the matriculation standard, which it said was mandatory for the post.

It also disputed her claim that she had studied Hindi during her BA.

Jai Mala held BA and B.Ed degrees, with Sanskrit and English as subjects. She had also studied Hindi in both Part-I and Part-II of her BA.
ADVERTISEMENT

A trial court dismissed her suit on May 18, 2006. The Rewari district judge upheld that decision on October 11, 2006, leaving her to approach the high court.

How did her BA Hindi marks help her win the case?

Before the high court, Jai Mala's counsel argued that the lower courts had overlooked her marksheets, which established that she had passed Hindi at the graduation level.
ADVERTISEMENT

She had scored 106 out of 200 marks in Hindi in BA Part-I and 89 out of 200 in Part-II. Her counsel argued that this was a higher academic qualification than the minimum Hindi knowledge prescribed for the teaching post.

The state counsel maintained that the earlier judgments were based on a proper assessment of the facts.

However, Justice Manuja found merit in Jai Mala's argument. Referring to Haryana government's instructions dated June 16, 1979, and a Supreme Court judgment, the high court held that her higher qualification in Hindi could not be disregarded simply because she had not studied the subject at matriculation level.

The judge also took note of the fact that education authorities had asked her to join the school before withholding the formal appointment order.

The court observed that asking her to join and subsequently withholding the appointment letter supported her case and reflected a lack of due diligence by the authorities.

What did Jai Mala say after the high court ruling?

With the high court ruling in her favour, Jai Mala told TOI that she was looking forward to entering a classroom despite having only five months of service left before retirement in April.

She said the outcome had finally brought an end to 27 years of struggle.

Her husband said their education helped them understand the legal process and continue fighting the case. He added that sustaining such a prolonged legal battle would have been extremely difficult for an ordinary family.

What benefits has the high court ordered?

The Punjab and Haryana High Court directed Haryana government to appoint Jai Mala as a Sanskrit teacher with effect from June 10, 1999, along with all consequential benefits.

The court also set aside the trial court's 2006 dismissal of her suit and the subsequent district court judgment upholding it.

The ruling means her appointment will be recognised from the original date specified by the court, rather than only from November 2026, when she is finally set to begin teaching.

Inputs from TOI
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Haryana woman waits 27 years for government job, gets appointed as teacher five months before retirement; was asked to join in 1999 but never received appointment letter
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+