Bengaluru taxi drivers are unhappy as Vietnam's Green SM plans 10,000 electric cabs with fares as low as Rs 8 per km

Bengaluru taxi and autorickshaw associations are opposing the proposed entry of Vietnam-based electric mobility company Green SM, citing concerns over its reported fares of Rs 8 per km compared with the Karnataka government's notified rate of Rs 2...

ET Online

Green SM

Bengaluru's taxi and autorickshaw operators have raised concerns over the proposed entry of Vietnam-based electric mobility company Green SM, fearing that its reportedly low fares could trigger a price war and put the livelihoods of local drivers at risk. The dispute centres on the company's reported plan to offer electric cab rides at around Rs 8 per kilometre. This is significantly lower than the Karnataka government's notified fare of Rs 24 per km for smaller taxis.

Transport associations argue that independent drivers, many of whom have bought their vehicles through bank loans, will struggle to compete with a company-backed fleet. They have pointed to expenses such as monthly loan instalments, insurance, permits and vehicle maintenance, which drivers must bear regardless of how much they earn.

At least four taxi and transport associations have approached Karnataka Governor Sudha Yadav, seeking intervention over Green SM's proposed operations in Bengaluru. In their representation, they have called for transparency on the permissions and licences granted to the company, along with an independent assessment of its potential impact on local transport operators.


Read more - India’s youngest Demat account holder is a six-day-old baby from Delhi: How infant Arya Goel set the record

"We welcome the transition towards environmentally sustainable transportation. However, such a transition must be implemented in a fair, transparent and inclusive manner, without discriminating against local operators," the associations said.

Why Bengaluru taxi drivers are worried about Green SM's fares

Nataraj Sharma, president of the Federation of Karnataka State Private Transport Associations, said local operators would find it difficult to match the proposed fares.
ADVERTISEMENT

Speaking to TOI, Sharma said there were currently no state government regulations governing fares charged by electric taxis. He added that Green SM could potentially offer rides for less than Rs 8 per km, while existing operators use petrol, diesel, CNG and LPG-powered vehicles.

"We will not be able to offer prices as low as them," he said.

Read more - Leave Delhi at 9 am & reach Lucknow by 11:12 am: Bullet train will connect two cities in just 2 hours 12 minutes, with economical fares

The federation has also raised concerns about the company's access to corporate funding, bulk vehicle purchases, its own booking app and fleet-management systems. It believes these advantages could put independent drivers under pressure to lower fares, even as they continue to pay their loan instalments and meet operating costs.
ADVERTISEMENT

Transport associations claim that nearly eight lakh families in Bengaluru depend on the passenger transport sector for their livelihood. They have sought a cap on Green SM's fleet size, an audit of its licence compliance and a review of its proposed fare structure.

Green SM denies charging Rs 8 per km

Green SM has rejected reports that it charges Rs 8 per km, describing the claims as "inaccurate and unfounded".
ADVERTISEMENT

The company said its fare details are available through its official website and communication channels. It also stated that passengers can view the fare on its app before confirming a booking.

The disagreement over fares has added to concerns among local operators, who argue that the entry of a large electric cab fleet could change the economics of the city's passenger transport market.

Karnataka government puts further Green SM registrations on hold

Amid the growing opposition, Karnataka Transport Minister Byrathi Suresh said Green SM had already secured registration for 100 taxis in Bengaluru. However, the Transport Department has instructed regional transport officials not to register any more vehicles operated by the company until further orders.

The minister said the government had received information that Green SM planned to register 10,000 electric taxis and charge between Rs 8 and Rs 10 per km. He expressed concern that such fares could affect the earnings of existing drivers.

"We have received information that they are planning to register 10,000 electric taxis and charge Rs 8 to Rs 10 per km. This will affect the livelihoods of people. I will discuss the issue with the chief minister. Representatives of the company had met me seeking permission. I have said no to them," Suresh said, as quoted by TOI.

He added that the government would decide on further registrations after discussions with Chief Minister D K Shivakumar, taking the interests of local drivers into account.

Green SM has announced plans to expand its electric cab services to Bengaluru and Chennai as part of a wider expansion across six Indian states and Union Territories. It is already operating in Delhi-NCR and Hyderabad.

What are the Karnataka government's notified taxi fares?

The controversy has also brought attention to Karnataka's existing taxi fare structure. Under the state government's February 2024 notification, fares are determined by the cost of the vehicle.

The notified fare structure is as follows:

  • Cars costing up to Rs 10 lakh: Minimum fare of Rs 100 for the first 4 km, followed by Rs 24 per km.
  • Cars costing between Rs 10 lakh and Rs 15 lakh: Minimum fare of Rs 115 for the first 4 km, followed by Rs 28 per km.
  • Cars costing above Rs 15 lakh: Minimum fare of Rs 130 for the first 4 km, followed by Rs 32 per km.
The notification also prescribes a waiting charge of Re 1 per minute. Passengers booking journeys between midnight and 6 am are required to pay an additional 10%.

Commuters divided over Green SM's Bengaluru entry

While transport associations have raised concerns about the impact on local livelihoods, some commuters have welcomed the prospect of another cab operator entering Bengaluru.

Supporters argue that greater competition could improve cab availability and give passengers more choices, potentially bringing down fares. Some social media users have also linked their support to complaints about autorickshaw drivers refusing rides or not using meters.

One user argued that more cab operators would give commuters greater choice, while another suggested that opposition to Green SM's entry was driven by the commercial interests of existing operators.


Inputs from TOI
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Bengaluru taxi drivers are unhappy as Vietnam's Green SM plans 10,000 electric cabs with fares as low as Rs 8 per km
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+