Bengaluru man pays Rs 90,000 for holiday membership, seeks refund within six weeks without using any benefits; consumer commission orders company to return money with 6% annual interest and pay Rs 5,000 in legal costs

Sangeeth Bhadran purchased a holiday membership for Rs 90,000 but decided to cancel after six weeks. He argued that the benefits promised did not match the actual terms of the agreement. The Karnataka State Consumer Commission ruled in favor of Bh...

ET Online

NCDRC has ordered Country Vacations to refund Rs 90,000 with 6% annual interest to a Bengaluru man who cancelled his holiday membership within six weeks without using any benefits (AI image)

The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) has ordered a company to refund Rs 90,000 to a Bengaluru man who cancelled his long-term holiday membership within six weeks without using any of its benefits. The commission ruled that the company could not refuse the refund by citing a 'no-refund' clause when the customer had not used any of its facilities, reported TOI.

The NCDRC dismissed a revision petition filed by Country Vacations and Country Club (India) Ltd, upholding the Karnataka State Consumer Commission's order directing the companies to refund the membership fee with 6% annual interest and pay Rs 5,000 in litigation costs.

Man paid Rs 90,000 after promotional call

According to the TOI report, Sangeeth Bhadran had received a promotional call from Country Vacations on December 2, 2013, offering holiday packages and inviting him to visit its office. Five days later, he visited the company's Bengaluru office, where he was offered holiday benefits, accommodation and discounts before signing a membership agreement and paying Rs 90,000.


After going through the agreement, Bhadran found that its terms did not match the benefits promised during the promotional interaction. He also said he had been assured that he would not have to pay maintenance charges for facilities he did not use. He subsequently sought to cancel the membership and get his money back, but the companies refused despite repeated emails, phone calls and personal visits.

What did Country Vacations say?

Country Vacations and Country Club then approached the NCDRC, arguing that Bhadran had voluntarily entered into the agreement after understanding its terms, including the non-refundable nature of the membership fee. The companies said membership cards and gift vouchers had been issued to him, but he had neither attempted to use the holiday facilities nor paid the mandatory annual maintenance charges. They denied any misrepresentation or deficiency in service and argued that he had failed to produce evidence to support his allegations.

NCDRC calls 'no-refund' clause patently unfair and unjust

- The NCDRC observed that Bhadran's failure to use the membership facilities did not justify the companies' unfair conduct or make one-sided contract terms valid.
ADVERTISEMENT

- It noted that Bhadran was invited to the company's office, where the membership benefits were explained and the agreement was signed on the same day.

- Bhadran sought to cancel the long-term membership within about six weeks without using any of its benefits.

- The commission called it 'patently unfair and unjust' for the companies to refuse a refund under the 'no-refund' clause while continuing to impose annual maintenance charges.

- It said the companies could have deducted a reasonable amount for the six-week period, along with administrative charges, before refunding the remaining money.
ADVERTISEMENT

- Keeping the entire membership fee despite Bhadran not using any benefits would result in unfair financial gain for the companies.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Bengaluru man pays Rs 90,000 for holiday membership, seeks refund within six weeks without using any benefits; consumer commission orders company to return money with 6% annual interest and pay Rs 5,000 in legal costs
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+