Vermont woman says neighbour repeatedly blocked her car with his truck, forcing her to crawl inside; she became fearful of going outside and lost sleep, court awards her $15,000

In a notable case in Vermont, David Burns was held liable for $15,000 for nuisance and trespassing against his neighbor, Misty McCartney. The court found that Burns consistently hindered McCartney's access to her vehicle by improperly parking his ...

Improper parking can prove costly. A Vermont man has learned this the hard way after a court upheld a $15,000 award to his neighbour, who said his truck was repeatedly parked so close to her car that she sometimes had to crawl through the passenger door to reach the driver's seat.

The case involves Misty McCartney and her neighbours, David Burns and Melissa Haberman, who share a gravel driveway between their properties. McCartney filed a lawsuit seeking damages for trespass and nuisance, along with other relief, over a dispute concerning the shared driveway and the neighbours' use of it.

According to the court's findings, Burns repeatedly parked his truck in the shared driveway in a way that blocked McCartney's access or made it extremely difficult for her to enter or exit her vehicle. On some occasions, he allegedly waited until McCartney had parked and gone inside her house before moving his truck close to her car. At other times, he positioned the vehicle before she returned home, making it difficult or impossible for her to use the driveway.


The dispute also involved other incidents. Burns allegedly pushed snow from his property into the shared driveway and onto McCartney's land during snow events. The court also noted an incident in which he deliberately left animal faeces near her back steps.

In the order, the court noted that defendant Burns began behaving in a passive-aggressive way toward plaintiff and her property rights after she brought the property in 2019. It also noted how Burns' "persistent, provocative, and pernicious campaign to interfere with plaintiff’s property rights."

McCartney said the incessant harassment also took an emotional toll on her. Owing to the annoyance, discomfort, and inconvenience, she became and fearful of going outside, and she lost sleep. The harassment impacted her work and relationships.
ADVERTISEMENT

Why did the court award $15,000?

The trial court concluded that Burns had committed multiple trespasses and created a continuing private nuisance by deliberately interfering with McCartney's use of the shared driveway. It awarded her $950 for physical damage to her vehicles and another $50 in nominal damages for multiple trespasses. The court separately awarded $15,000 as compensation for the annoyance, discomfort and inconvenience caused by the nuisance.

It also issued a permanent injunction against Burns and Haberman to prevent further violations of McCartney's property rights.

Vermont Supreme Court upholds $15,000 award

Burns and Haberman challenged the trial court's decision, disputing its interpretation of the shared driveway agreement and the property rights involved.

However, the Vermont Supreme Court rejected their appeal and affirmed the lower court's decision in January 2026.
ADVERTISEMENT

The ruling means the $15,000 nuisance award remains in place, alongside the separate damages for vehicle damage and trespass.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › International › World News › Vermont woman says neighbour repeatedly blocked her car with his truck, forcing her to crawl inside; she became fearful of going outside and lost sleep, court awards her $15,000
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+