Trump-Xi-Putin summit: Can the three find common ground on war, oil, nukes?

With Trump, Xi and Putin coming together, Shenzhen could produce an extraordinary diplomatic spectacle, but without delivering an extraordinary outcome. The real test will not be the great photo-op, but whether the three can use their power to avo...

Trump, Putin and Xi have different, oftentimes competing interests on most matters. That's what makes the Shenzhen meeting fascinating.

An upcoming meeting between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, scheduled to be held in Shenzhen on November 19 on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, has captured the world's attention. The remarkable moment comes amid major geopolitical turmoil and unprecedented disruptions in global energy markets in the wake of the festering war in Iran.

The epoch-making nature of the occasion has sparked huge speculations as to what the American President, the Chinese President and the Russian President discuss about when they meet at such a delicate moment as this, when the stakes are sky-high for each of them.

Also read | China resumes storing crude oil, giving it fuel export options


As three of the world’s most powerful leaders prepare to sit at the same table in the backdrop of a war that has wrecked global trade and left economies badly struggling, all eyes are on whether it's going to be just symbolism or whether it leads to some real, meaningful change that can put world affairs back on track.

Nuclear disarmament, the Iran crisis and the future of global power equations could be on table when the three come together, some say, but all details at the moment remain, at best, vague.

A major event amid big disorder

Coming in the backdrop of two unending wars and increasingly costly trade chaos, the timing of the meeting could not have been more significant.
ADVERTISEMENT

It also comes amid so-far-unsuccessful efforts to meaningfully settle the US-China trade & diplomaequation, with major sticking points -- tariffs, technology curbs, supply chain troubles -- continuing to cloud ties.

The Iran war is a particularly critical factor. What began as a military confrontation in West Asia has turned into a crisis with consequences far beyond the immediate region. Attacks on commercial ships in and around the Strait of Hormuz, through which a huge share of the world's oil passes, have threatened energy supplies and shipping itself.

Significantly, the war has also exposed the vulnerability of global trade to disruptions at strategic maritime chokepoints, Bloomberg reported.

Although oil markets have come down from their most alarming levels on expectations of de-escalation, the underlying uncertainty remains.
ADVERTISEMENT

Attacks on 37 ships during October, the highest monthly tally since the war began, showed why a political agreement alone will not likely be enough to restore normal shipping. Mine clearance, insurance premiums and the willingness of shipowners to send vessels through dangerous waters may keep causing additional problem for a long time, Reuters reported last week.

Enough common ground...

Although their individual interests differ from each other, this gives Trump, Xi and Putin a shared reason to discuss the West Asia situation.
ADVERTISEMENT

According to an AP report, Trump wants an exit from a costly war and an arrangement that can restore stability to energy markets, while Xi's major interest lies in retaining China's access to oil and bring world trade back to normal. Putin, meanwhile, may be seeking to use the war to show Russia's importance in global energy and security considerations, the report said.

Also read | Kremlin dismisses comparison of Xi-Trump-Putin summit to 1945 Yalta carve-up

For Trump, the biggest opportunity may lie in nuclear diplomacy, Reuters reported, as the last US-Russia nuclear arms control agreement -- New START --expired in February, ending restrictions on the world's two largest nuclear powers for the first time in more than half a century.

Trump apparently wants a new system that also includes China in the equation, with some of his officials having said that reducing nuclear weapons proliferation is a matter of trilateral discussion.

There might emerge a major obstacle to this, though. China has consistently maintained that Trump and Putin must first reduce their substantially larger nuclear stockpiles before Xi can be expected to accept a restriction on his nukes.

As per Pentagon estimates cited by Reuters, China's arsenal is at more than 600 warheads, against more than 5,000 each for the US and Russia.

In light of this, a binding trilateral nuke agreement seems too early a matter for this meeting. What could be on the table at Shenzhen, instead, is how to set a road map to begin the process of discussion, Reuters reported.

...but major individual agenda too

Xi's calculation is not likely limited to just nuclear weapons; power projection seems to be a major part of it.

Hosting the meeting allows China to project itself as a big diplomatic power at a time when Trump's policies have wrecked global trade.

China would prefer the APEC summit to focus on economic cooperation, commerce and regional stability; it will not likely want the event to become a platform for nuke curb talks.

Also, as said above, Xi will also likely be unwilling to make the same commitment as Trump and Putin, without possessing the same number of weapons that they do.

As for Putin, this meeting could be a big opening. He can again show the world that Russia can't be kept out of big global-level talks. A high-publicity meet with Trump and Xi will help Putin reinforce Russia's importance in world affairs despite it current pariah-like status.

Reuters had reported that Putin is also likely to seek a discussion of the European security architecture, and the possibility of a settlement in Ukraine.

Biggest fault line

Ukraine, if it is talked about at the meeting, will be a complicated challenge.

Putin would like to push for a settlement on his terms. Trump is pushing for an end to the war at any cost, and he will consider it a major diplomatic feat for himself if the fighting stops. Xi has resisted the idea of turning the trilateral meeting into a platform for deciding an European war's outcome.

US's messaging on the issue has also not been consistent. Trump officials had initially said Ukraine won't be part of the meeting. Trump, however, said on November 17 that he intends to raise the war with Xi and Putin, AP reported.

Even if the matter comes up at the meeting, any attempt to decide Ukraine's fate without involving Kyiv and European govts will likely trigger major resistance, a Reuters report said.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has repeatedly insisted that decisions about his country's territory and security cannot be made without it being directly involved in the process.

It may be noted here that the Shenzhen conference has drawn comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference, where America's Roosevelt, Britain's Churchill and Soviet Union's Stalin carved up post-WWII nations without paying any heed to other countries. Kremlin has denied any such plan, but concerns have lingered.

This difficult situation makes a comprehensive talk on Ukraine very unlikely at Shenzhen. At most, the three could just set the path for more talks elsewhere.

Historic photo-op, or a real historic breakthrough?

A big question now is, will the meeting deliver anything beyond a declaration of intent?

There is certainly scope for small-scale pacts, such as an agreement to continue nuke talks, set up a mechanism for further consultations, exchange views on Iran and encourage diplomatic efforts to stabilise oil markets

While these would be useful agreements, they will fall well short of a big outcome, a Reuters report said.

The obstacles are big: China has no incentive to accept a nuke cut on American and Russian terms. Russia and Ukraine are bitterly divided over a settlement. Besides, Trump, Putin and Xi also have different, oftentimes competing interests in West Asia in particular and in oil trade in general.

Also, it can be noted that even on trade, the three sides' differences over tariffs, technology and strategic competition are stark and haven't been solved.

It is hard to miss the meeting's symbolism and the momentousness of the occasion, though. It brings together the presidents of three nations that possess enormous military, economic and diplomatic powers. Besides, it allows the much-vilified Putin to stand alongside the world's two most powerful leaders, while allowing China to show that it can set the agenda for such a critical meeting, Reuters reported.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › International › World News › Trump-Xi-Putin summit: Can the three find common ground on war, oil, nukes?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+