Michigan woman's garage, basement flooded after neighbouring business allegedly changed drainage system; court awards $50,000 for emotional distress
A Michigan resident was awarded $102,000 in damages after her neighbor's drainage changes led to significant water challenges at her property. The Michigan Court of Appeals validated her claims of trespass and nuisance against the adjacent commerc...

The excessive water drainage allegedly continued for years, damaging several parts of the residential property. (AI-generated image for representation)
As per the court documents shared by the Justia, the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld Sherilyn Hart's claims of trespass and nuisance in fact against North Waverly LLC, the owner of a commercial property next to her house. It also upheld the $50,000 award for emotional distress and mental anguish under the nuisance claim, according to the court's November 5, 2026 opinion. The appeals court, however, modified the economic damages awarded by the trial court after finding that certain repair expenses had effectively been counted twice.
The case arose from a dispute involving Hart's residential property at 1324 N. Waverly Road and North Waverly's commercial property at 1300 N. Waverly Road. Hart purchased the residential property with her husband, Anthony McCarty, in 2013. The couple intended to renovate the house and eventually rent it out. Hart was the property's sole titleholder.
According to their trial testimony, there was no water damage or excessive runoff on the property when they purchased it. The drainage problems began in May 2016, after North Waverly allegedly modified the drainage system on its commercial property. The company removed extensions from the building's downspouts and connected them to two long, black corrugated plastic pipes. The pipes directed collected rainwater towards the boundary between the two properties. One pipe emptied water directly onto Hart's property, while the other discharged water just beneath the ground across the property line.
McCarty testified that the water flowed across the yard, collected around the garage and sometimes entered the house during heavy rainfall. He also said he had warned the commercial property's owner about the potential problem in June 2016. The owner reportedly told him that the pipe was temporary and would eventually be moved underneath the parking lot.
However, according to McCarty, the front collector pipe remained in place for nearly six years.
Basement flooding damaged house and garage
The excessive water drainage allegedly continued for years, damaging several parts of the residential property. According to the court record, water repeatedly pooled around the garage and the eastern wall of the house. The basement wall began bowing inward in late 2016 and eventually moved off its foundation sill. The damage became severe enough that the house had to be jacked up so the wall could be replaced. Repairs were also required on the northern and southern basement walls.The process of raising the house reportedly cracked plaster throughout the property and caused roof leaks, requiring additional repairs. The flooding also damaged a new furnace, central air-conditioning unit and gas water heater in the basement. The property's concrete driveway suffered damage from constant water pooling, while the basement sump pump repeatedly failed.
McCarty testified that the couple went through five sump pump motors during the ordeal. He estimated that they spent between $60,000 and $65,000 repairing the house, excluding most of the garage repairs.
The couple also tried several measures to address the drainage problem themselves. In 2018, McCarty rented earth-moving equipment, dug a trench and installed a larger sump line and a commercial-grade sump pump to remove water entering the basement. In June 2020, he capped the two collector pipes. The saturated soil around the house subsequently began drying out, according to his testimony. He later installed a water-return system that collected the drainage water and pumped it back towards the commercial property.
The system worked for approximately 90 days before the couple removed it following a township violation notice.
Court rejects business owner's arguments
Hart filed a lawsuit in 2022, alleging trespass and nuisance, among other claims. McCarty was initially named as a plaintiff but was dismissed during the trial because he was not the property's registered titleholder or a person in possession of it.The commercial property owner also filed a counterclaim seeking ownership of the disputed portion of land occupied by the retaining wall, arguing adverse possession. Following a four-day trial, the circuit court ruled in Hart's favour on the trespass and nuisance claims.
It initially awarded $150,000 in economic damages, $50,000 for emotional distress and mental anguish, and $40,000 in attorney fees, taking the total to $240,000. However, the trial court later removed the attorney fees and reduced the economic damages by 20%, holding the defendant responsible for 80% of those damages. This brought the amended judgment to $170,000.
North Waverly subsequently challenged the ruling before the Michigan Court of Appeals.
In its November 5, 2026 decision, the appeals court upheld the findings that the company's drainage modifications caused excessive water to flow onto Hart's property. However, it found that the trial court had incorrectly calculated the repair costs by effectively counting certain expenses twice.
The appeals court determined that $65,000 was a fair estimate of the economic damages based on McCarty's testimony. After applying the 20% reduction for comparative responsibility, it modified the economic damages to $52,000. The appeals court also reversed the award of noneconomic damages insofar as it related to the trespass claim. However, it upheld the separate $50,000 award for emotional distress and mental anguish under the nuisance-in-fact claim.
The court also upheld the dismissal of North Waverly's adverse-possession counterclaim. It directed the lower court to clarify the remedial work required on the retaining wall to the extent that it continued to encroach on Hart's property.
The decision was issued by a three-judge panel comprising Randy J. Wallace, Thomas C. Cameron and Daniel S. Korobkin.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.