MLB All-Star Game sees TV ratings drop despite 'swing-off' spectacle

The first-ever 'swing-off' in MLB All-Star Game history brought drama to Truist Park on Tuesday night - but even that novelty wasn’t enough to reverse the event’s ratings decline.

This year’s Midsummer Classic averaged a 3.8 rating and drew 7.19 million viewers on Fox, according to Nielsen. That’s a 3% dip from the 7.44 million who tuned in last year, making it the second-lowest rated All-Star Game on record. Still, the viewership narrowly topped the all-time low of 7 million set in 2023.

ALSO READ: Kyle Schwarber lifts NL to historic 'swing-off' win at All-Star Game


Despite the dip, baseball’s All-Star showcase remains ahead of its peers in the ratings game. The NBA All-Star Game and the NFL’s Pro Bowl Games each averaged 4.7 million viewers this year, while Monday night’s Home Run Derby drew 5.73 million on ESPN.

ALSO READ - Swing-off Explained: MLB uses new rule for first time in All-Star Game

Tuesday's game reached its peak during the 9:15PM ET window with 8.1 million viewers, making it Fox’s most-watched program since the Super Bowl. That spike coincided with the debut of the 'swing-off' - a new tiebreaker format implemented after a 2022 rule change, giving fans a surprise finale to the exhibition contest.

Each participant got three swings. Brent Rooker homered twice, and Kyle Stowers added one for the American League. Randy Arozarena responded with one for the National League before Kyle Schwarber stole the show by launching all three of his swings out of the park. Jonathan Aranda followed for the AL but went 0-for-3, clinching a wild 7–6 win for the National League - just their second All-Star victory in the last 12 years.

"It was interesting," said Schwarber, who became the first Phillies player to win All-Star Game MVP since Johnny Callison in 1964. "Exciting, fun. There’s a lot of guys who deserve this [trophy], but I’m glad it’s going home with us to Philly."

For the 41,702 fans in attendance, the unexpected swing-off added a dramatic twist. For MLB, however, even fireworks and history weren't quite enough to reverse the ongoing trend of declining national TV viewership.