Here's why this NYC pastor was disciplined over pop star Sabrina Carpenter's racy video

A recent music video shoot featuring pop artist Sabrina Carpenter at Brooklyn's Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin Mary Church has sparked significant controversy, leading to action against Monsignor Jamie J. Gigantiello. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn took decisive steps, relieving Gigantiello of his administrative duties at Our Lady of Mt. Carmel-Annunciation Parish in Williamsburg after the release of Carpenter's video for “Feather” on Halloween.

Gaining rapid traction with over 11 million views within a month, Carpenter's music video depicts her dancing amidst pastel-colored coffins within the 160-year-old church, donning a striking black dress, and a veil, stirring strong reactions within the community.

Brooklyn Bishop Robert Brennan, expressing his profound dismay, conducted a mass aiming to re-consecrate the church, seeking to restore its sanctity following the controversial filming incident. Additionally, Auxiliary Bishop Witold Mroziewski was appointed as a temporary parish administrator while Gigantiello undergoes a review process.


In a heartfelt letter to parishioners, Gigantiello sought forgiveness for what he termed an oversight. He explained that the decision to permit filming was based on the understanding that the majority of the shoot would occur outside the church premises. He emphasized his lack of awareness regarding the provocative nature of the scenes filmed inside the church and expressed deep regret over the situation.

The community response has been mixed, with some staunchly supporting Gigantiello, acknowledging his positive contributions to the community and his charitable endeavors. However, concerns have been raised about maintaining the sanctity of sacred spaces, questioning the appropriateness of utilizing religious institutions for creative ventures.

Despite Gigantiello facing repercussions, acknowledgment has been made of his previous positive engagements within the community, including his decision to donate the video's proceeds to a pregnancy crisis center.