Cornell scientists studied how 2,839 fish species swim together; their analysis found group swimming evolved around 60 times but disappeared about 320 times
A comprehensive study on fish collective movement has found that this behavior has independently evolved across numerous species over time. Surprisingly, about 79 percent of fish utilize collective movement, while others favor solitary habits. How...

A school of fish swimming together, as it gives them many eyes that can scan for food or threats. Image credits: Wikipedia
A study bigger than your average fish tank
As per the Cornell Chronicle article, the researchers looked into collective movement amongst 2,839 species (nearly 10 per cent of the total 39,000 living species). This is one of the largest studies done on the evolution of behaviour within a group of species. They trained a text transformer (the same technique utilised in large language models) to read textual descriptions of species. They also utilised machine learning to look at images taken by citizens from iNaturalist and other sources to see if the fish were moving cohesively.

The plot twist: leaving the group
According to the Cornell Chronicle, senior author Andrew Hein said that the experts expected collective movement to rarely be lost, but they found hundreds of examples of collective movement evolving in a lineage and then being lost in a solitary daughter species. The obvious reason for group movement is that it is safe. Species at the bottom of the food chain were more likely to move collectively.

So why quit? This is currently unknown. The researchers suspect that collective movement comes with three downsides: false alarms causing the whole school to scatter, increased competition for food, and increased risk of disease on longer time scales. Funding for the study came from the National Science Foundation.
The false-alarm problem, up close
One of these three downsides, the false-alarm problem, already has some earlier evidence behind it. Cornell Chronicle’s coverage of a 2023 PNAS paper titled “Wild animals suppress the spread of socially transmitted misinformation” noted that footage of wild coral reef fish in French Polynesia revealed individuals within schools scattering to seek shelter in the absence of a threat approximately every 8 minutes.
They found that fish in high-density schools decreased their sensitivity to startle cues from nearby fish, lowering the odds that a false alarm would spread through the group. This suggests that other animals, maybe even humans, could have similar mechanisms, although further research is required. Imagine mimicking a crowd crossing the road and finding out the light is still red.
Although this was a study looking into fish evolution, and the researchers do not claim it to be anything else, it is a good reminder that even creatures who have practised ‘everyone’s doing it’ for 350 million years have never had a perfect strategy.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.