Big Mistakes Season 2: Has the comedy series been renewed? Here’s what Dan Levy revealed about the return

The future of Big Mistakes Season 2 remains uncertain, but growing audience interest and a dramatic Season 1 finale have kept hopes alive for a renewal on Netflix. Created by Dan Levy and Rachel Sennott, the dark comedy has sparked conversation for its mix of crime, satire and dysfunctional family dynamics.

While there is no official confirmation yet, the show’s cliffhanger ending and creator hints suggest that plans for Big Mistakes Season 2 may already be taking shape behind the scenes.

Renewal Status: Will Big Mistakes Season 2 Happen?

As of now, Netflix has not formally renewed Big Mistakes for a second season. Early viewership data indicates a modest start, with the series reportedly garnering around 2.7 million views and over 12 million viewing hours in its opening days, as per a report by What’s On Netflix.




The show did manage to enter the platform’s global Top 10 charts, though at a lower rank compared to other releases. Industry observers note that renewal decisions often depend on long-term metrics such as completion rates and audience retention, not just initial numbers.

Despite the lukewarm debut, the series has shown signs of steady growth in daily rankings, which could strengthen its chances of renewal in the coming weeks.

Plot Recap: How Season 1 Sets Up a Bigger Story

Big Mistakes follows two unlikely siblings, pastor Nicky and school teacher Morgan, who accidentally get entangled in organised crime after stealing a necklace. What begins as a misstep quickly spirals into a dangerous arrangement with a powerful mob network.

The Season 1 finale delivers a major twist, revealing Annette as the mastermind behind the criminal operation. The discovery raises the stakes significantly, especially as Morgan is pressured into marrying Annette’s son, Max.

The ending leaves multiple questions unanswered, positioning Big Mistakes Season 2 as a potential escalation of chaos, danger and moral conflict.

What to Expect from Big Mistakes Season 2

Speaking about the show’s future, Dan Levy has hinted that the story is far from over. He suggested that if renewed, the next season would dive deeper into the consequences of the siblings’ actions.



Season 2 is expected to explore:

• Morgan’s uncertain engagement to Max and its implications
• Nicky’s struggle with his identity and role as a pastor
• The siblings’ deeper involvement in the mob’s operations
• The evolving dynamic between Annette and her son

Levy has also teased that the narrative will become “bigger and better,” with higher stakes and fewer escape routes for the protagonists.

Cast and Characters: Who Could Return?

If renewed, the core cast is expected to reprise their roles, including:

• Dan Levy as Nicky
• Taylor Ortega as Morgan
• Elizabeth Perkins as Annette
• Jack Innanen as Max

The interplay between these characters, particularly the tension between family loyalty and criminal obligations, is likely to remain central to the storyline.

Why Fans Are Still Hopeful

Despite mixed initial numbers, the strong creative backing of Dan Levy, known for his success with Schitt’s Creek, gives the series credibility and potential staying power.

With unresolved storylines and a growing fanbase, many believe Big Mistakes Season 2 could still secure a renewal if momentum continues.

FAQs

Is Big Mistakes Season 2 confirmed?

No, Netflix has not officially renewed the series yet.

What is Big Mistakes about?

The show follows two siblings who accidentally enter the world of organised crime and must navigate dangerous situations.