After its 1969 rejection as a Rembrandt, a family-inherited painting was identified by the Rijksmuseum as a genuine 1633 work after two years of research

An inherited painting has been confirmed as an authentic Rembrandt masterpiece after years of speculation. Previously dismissed as a mere work from his workshop, cutting-edge techniques like infrared imaging and X-rays applied by the Rijksmuseum p...

A self-portrait of Rembrandt van Rijn, whose long-disputed painting Vision of Zacharias in the Temple was authenticated after a two-year investigation by the Rijksmuseum. (Image credit: Wikimedia Commons)

For more than 55 years, one family owned a painting that art experts believed was not a genuine Rembrandt. After specialists turned down the painting in the 1960s, it was thought that the matter was solved and the piece remained in private hands. However, things changed when the family took the painting to the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, where experts conducted two years of research and proved that the painting was a genuine Rembrandt painted in 1633. Smithsonian Magazine reports that modern analysis overturned a decision that had stood for more than five decades.

By the early 1630s, Rembrandt van Rijn already belonged to the elite circle of painters in the Dutch Republic. His fame stemmed from depicting the intricacies of light and shadow in different works dealing with biblical narratives and portraits. Today, only a limited number of paintings are securely attributed to him, making every authenticated work significant to museums and art historians. The family painting Vision of Zacharias in the Temple was created in 1633, when Rembrandt, then 27, was still building his reputation in Amsterdam. Centuries later, after it had entered the family's collection, scholars came to believe it had been painted by another artist from Rembrandt's workshop.

The painting no one believed was a Rembrandt


The painting was not always considered a copy. Earlier, scholars believed it to be a Rembrandt, but that changed in 1969, when respected Rembrandt expert Horst Gerson removed it from the artist's catalogue. He believed that parts of the painting, including some of the figures, lacked the quality expected of Rembrandt and were probably completed by someone in the artist's workshop. Once that opinion was published, museums and collectors accepted the new attribution. The painting then spent more than five decades outside Rembrandt's official body of work. It was extremely difficult to determine whether the painting was a genuine Rembrandt because the Dutch master ran a busy workshop where students learned by copying his techniques. Some paintings were realized exclusively by pupils while others might have been done partly by Rembrandt together with his workshop helpers. Consequently, expert researchers have been discussing the authorship of many paintings for many years, including Vision of Zacharias in the Temple.

When the family inherited the painting, they were aware of its history but had no reason to think that the verdict would be overturned. Still, they decided to ask the experts at Amsterdam’s Rijksmuseum to take another look. That decision began a fresh investigation into a painting that many experts had considered settled. According to the Rijksmuseum, it took the Rijksmuseum roughly two years to re-examine the work before it reached its new conclusion.

How modern scans uncovered details earlier experts could not see
ADVERTISEMENT

Rijksmuseum_Amsterdam (1)
<p>Exp​erts at Amsterdam's Rijksmuseum spent two years examining the painting before confirming it as a genuine Rembrandt. (Image credit: Wikimedia Commons)<br></p>
Rather than relying only on the painting's appearance, Rijksmuseum researchers examined how it had actually been made. They applied infrared imaging, X-rays, and microscopic examination to peer under the visible paint layers, in search of clues left by the artist while the painting was still being created. These scans revealed underdrawings, changes in composition, and brushwork that matched Rembrandt's working methods during the early 1630s. Researchers also investigated the pigments and the wood support and discovered that they were similar to those of other known paintings from the same era. Together, the evidence suggested the painting was not a workshop copy but an original work completed by Rembrandt himself in 1633.

The painting captured a turning point in Rembrandt's career

Rembrandt_van_Rijn-De_Nachtwacht-1642 (1)
<p>Rembrandt's The Night Watch (1642) exemplifies the dramatic lighting and expressive style that also helped researchers identify Vision of Zacharias in the Temple as a genuine work by the Dutch master. (Image credit: Wikimedia Commons)<br></p>
The painting, Vision of Zacharias in the Temple, depicts the scene from the Bible when the priest Zacharias receives the angel Gabriel's message that he and his wife Elizabeth will become the parents of John the Baptist. The dramatic lighting, expressive faces, and the carefully arranged figures are typical of the style that Rembrandt started to develop shortly after he arrived in Amsterdam, when he was establishing his reputation as one of the greatest painters in Europe. Researchers believe the painting comes from a particularly important period in the artist's life. During the early 1630s, Rembrandt was working with large commissions and was exploring the expressive possibilities of light and shadow, an aspect that was also noticed during the examination in the Rijksmuseum.

The painting finally returned to Rembrandt
ADVERTISEMENT

The Rijksmuseum's announcement greatly increased the painting's estimated value. It restored the work to Rembrandt's catalogue after more than five decades and changed how historians understand one part of his early career. For the family that had quietly owned the painting, the Rijksmuseum's findings confirmed that the 1969 rejection had been incorrect. It also illustrated the ongoing way in which scientific analysis is redefining art history. Technologies that bring out the evidence under the paint can be applied to decisions made decades ago based on visual comparisons and photographs alone, and allow historians to reevaluate long-held opinions with much greater accuracy.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › International › US News › After its 1969 rejection as a Rembrandt, a family-inherited painting was identified by the Rijksmuseum as a genuine 1633 work after two years of research
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+