When power becomes an epic political spectacle

In the Indian context, spirituality is often presented as a spectacle that distracts from real governance issues. The rituals and festivals are designed to engage the populace while actual power remains hidden. Many citizens have limited access to...

PTI
The Balinese theatre state: the pomp of power on display, while the real machinery of governance remains hidden behind the scenes.
In 1980, American anthropologist Clifford Geertz published Negara, a short book about the kingdoms of 19th century Bali. These kingdoms puzzled him because they did very little actual governing. They had no great standing armies and no serious tax machinery. They had ceremony instead. Royal cremations took months to prepare. There were tooth-filing rites and temple festivals, and the king sat at the centre like an idol while thousands came to look. Geertz called it the theatre state and summed it up in one line: "Power served pomp, not pomp power."

There is a detail in Geertz that most people skip. The real business of Balinese life, the irrigation that fed the rice terraces, was not run by the king at all. Farmers' associations called subak ran it. The palace put on the show and the water flowed through other hands.

Romans had their own version. Juvenal sneered that the Roman mob wanted only two things, bread and circuses. Gladiators bled in the arena, the crowd roared and nobody asked awkward questions about the Senate. That was distraction through blood. The Indian version is cleverer, because it uses spirituality. A man can walk out of a stadium in disgust. Walking out of a festival is harder, since it looks like walking out on the divine.


Look at Indian screens as elections approach. Pilgrim sites, corridors, temple inaugurations, festivals with crowds that stretch to the horizon, films about gods and warrior kings. Everybody is gathering to see something sacred. What is missing is just as telling: jobs, roads, hospitals, prices, the dull material facts of life. Spirituality has become a spectacle, and its purpose is to make people feel that all is well. People who feel good vote the way they are expected to.

To see how this works, go inside a South Indian temple. The Agama texts that govern temple ritual distinguish between images. There is dhruva bera, also called moola murti or sthayi murti, the fixed stone image in the dark sanctum. It never moves. Then there is the utsava bera, the festival image, usually bronze, made to be carried out. The great Chola bronze workshops of the 10th to 12th centuries produced the finest of these: dancing Nataraja, family group of Shiva, Uma and Skanda.

Why did the god need a portable double? Part of the answer is theology. Another part is plain social fact. For most of Indian history, large sections of the population were not allowed inside the temple. The sanctum belonged to priests, patrons, kings and the "pure" castes. The rest stood outside. This did not change by itself. It took the Vaikom Satyagraha of 1924 and the Travancore Temple Entry Proclamation of 1936 to open some doors, and even then only some. So, the bronze came out on a chariot on festival days, decked in silk and flowers, so the excluded could see a god they were not permitted to approach. The people got the parade. The sanctum stayed sealed.
ADVERTISEMENT

Now apply this to politics. The theatre state needs an utsava murti. This is the leader who is garlanded, carried and paraded, who appears at every ceremony, makes every right noise and says exactly what the crowd wants to hear. He glitters. He moves. He is seen. What he does not do is run things.

Behind him sits the moola murti, the unmoving deity, invisible in the dark: a vast apparatus of bureaucrats, contractors and financiers, quietly moving wealth and power to the people who manage the actual machinery. The crowd worships the bronze. The stone stays where it always was, and so does the money.

The merchant lobby of India worked this out a thousand years ago. Temple towns were always market towns. Merchant guilds such as the Ainnurruvar gave lavishly to temples. Inscriptions on the walls of the Brihadeeswara temple at Thanjavur record the temple lending money to village assemblies at interest. The temple was a bank as much as a shrine. Traders understood something devotees did not: piety and profit sit very comfortably together, as long as the devotee is watching the procession and not the ledger.

Geertz thought the Balinese pomp was its own end, a genuine expression of cosmic order, not a cover for anything. The Indian version has reversed him. Here pomp serves power, and power serves capital. The theatre is no longer the point. It is the curtain. Those dazzled by the social media narrative procession rarely ask who holds the key to the sanctum, and who holds the account books.
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › India › When power becomes an epic political spectacle
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+