India slams Pakistan’s ‘echo chamber’ politics at UN meet, says critics living in ‘La-La Land’

In yet another instance of diplomatic sparring between India and Pakistan, New Delhi has mounted a forceful rebuttal to Pakistan at the ongoing session of the UN Human Rights Council. It dismissed Islamabad’s allegations on Jammu and Kashmir as “propaganda” and accused it of attempting to misuse multilateral platforms.

Exercising India’s Right of Reply during the high-level segment, First Secretary Anupama Singh said New Delhi was compelled to respond to references made by Pakistan and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC).

She rejected the charges outright, remarking that the grouping had allowed itself to become an “echo chamber” for one member state.


“We categorically reject these allegations,” Singh said, adding that Pakistan’s “incessant propaganda reeks of envy.” While India had no intention of dignifying the claims, she said, it was necessary to “dismantle them with facts.”

Reaffirming India’s long-held position, Singh asserted that “Jammu and Kashmir was, is, and will always remain an integral and inalienable part of India.”

She maintained that the region’s accession to India in 1947 was “completely legal and irrevocable,” in accordance with the Indian Independence Act and international law.

She further stated that the only unresolved issue was Pakistan’s “illegal occupation of Indian territories,” urging Islamabad to vacate areas under its control.

‘La-La Land’

Highlighting infrastructure and economic strides in the Union Territory, Singh pointed to the Chenab Rail Bridge, described as the world’s highest railway bridge, inaugurated in Jammu and Kashmir last year.

“If the Chenab Rail Bridge… is fake, then Pakistan must be hallucinating or living in ‘La-La land’,” she said in a pointed response.

Drawing a comparison that underscored India’s development narrative, Singh said Jammu and Kashmir’s development budget exceeds, by more than double, the recent bailout package Pakistan sought from the International Monetary Fund.

If that was hard to believe, she suggested, it reflected Islamabad’s detachment from ground realities.

Responding to criticism of democratic processes, Singh said it was difficult to accept lectures on democracy from a country where elected governments seldom complete full terms.

She cited voter participation in recent general and assembly elections in Jammu and Kashmir as evidence that people in the region have chosen democratic engagement over violence.

Concluding her remarks, Singh accused Pakistan of pursuing “relentless state-sponsored terrorism” while attempting to mask its own internal crises through rhetorical offensives on international platforms.