India, Bangladesh stare at rough waters as a critical deadline approaches

The Ganga Water treaty is up for renewal. A failure to do so could impact both India and Bangladesh, further souring already fragile ties. If the two governments allow the December 12 deadline to pass without even an interim understanding, the con...

ANI
Ganga Water Treaty: Failure to reach an agreement in just over three weeks from now might reopen one of the most sensitive feuds between India and Bangladesh.
The 30-year Ganga Water Sharing Treaty between India and Bangladesh, which was signed by the two sides in 1996, is due to expire on December 12, 2026. The renewal negotiations of the treaty are taking place amid significant political uncertainty, lingering disagreements over water share and multiple sour notes in broader bilateral ties.

For a river that has had a huge role in shaping the destinies of the two neighbouring nations, the Ganga long been a source of discord. As its waters flow from India towards the Bay of Bengal, the question of who gets how much during the dry months has often put India and Bangladesh on a diplomatic crossroads.

Also read | Quad sets up biz forum, strengthens maritime intelligence ties


While Bangladesh wants what is says is "a fairer and more dependable sharing arrangement", India has its own concerns about water availability, upstream requirements and the implications of making new commitments.

The stakes have reached way beyond water. The issues on the table now also involve food security, livelihoods, regional clout and the future of a relationship already under considerable stress. Failure to reach an agreement in just over three weeks from now might reopen one of the most sensitive feuds between the two sides.

Ganga Water Treaty: How it works

The roots of the dispute go back to the construction of the Farakka Barrage in West Bengal, commissioned in 1975.
ADVERTISEMENT

India built it to divert water from the Ganga into the Bhagirathi-Hooghly river system, helping maintain navigable depths for Kolkata Port. Bangladesh, the downstream riparian country, feared that the diversion would lessen water availability in its territory, especially in the dry season.

The disagreement became a major irritant after Bangladesh's independence. There followed many rounds of negotiations and temporary water-sharing arrangements before the two sides reached a long-term settlement in 1996.

The agreement was signed on December 12, 1996, by the then Indian PM H D Deve Gowda and Bangladesh PM Sheikh Hasina. It covers the five-month lean season, January 1 to May 31, when river flows are relatively low. Water availability is measured at Farakka and distributed in successive 10-day periods.

The formula is based on the river's historical average flows between 1949 and 1988, an ET report says. Under the pact, both countries have committed to make efforts to protect those flows.
ADVERTISEMENT

The allocation formula, as per the treaty text, has three thresholds:

  • When availability is 70,000 cusecs or less: India and Bangladesh receive 50% each.
  • When availability is between 70,000 and 75,000 cusecs: Bangladesh receives a fixed 35,000 cusecs, while India gets the balance.
  • When availability is 75,000 cusecs or more: India receives 40,000 cusecs, with Bangladesh getting the remaining water.
There is also a specific minimum-flow provision. Between March 11 and May 10, each country is entitled to get at least 35,000 cusecs during alternate three 10-day periods. If the flow at Farakka falls below 50,000 cusecs during any 10-day period, the two governments must immediately consult to make emergency adjustments based on equity, fairness and avoiding harm to either side.
ADVERTISEMENT

Also read | India-Asean Summit in Manila: PM Modi calls for unity to ensure regional peace and stability

The treaty stops India from cutting the water released for Bangladesh downstream of Farakka. It also stipulates reasonable consumption -- not exceeding 200 cusecs.

Why both sides are unhappy

Bangladesh's main objection is that the "existing arrangement does not provide an adequate and sufficiently dependable minimum supply during periods of severe water scarcity".

The Ganga is indispensable to irrigation, agriculture, fisheries and livelihoods across Bangladesh's north-western districts, it says. When water is not enough, the consequences reach the Padma river system and the Sundarbans ecosystem, Dhaka argues.

Bangladesh is not keen on extending the existing arrangement. Rather, it is pushing for a revised agreement that gives it more water guarantees.

It may be noted that the 1977 pact, which preceded the current arrangement, had a minimum-guarantee clause that assured Bangladesh of 80% of its scheduled allocation during the lean season.

Bangladesh is now pushing for that guarantee to be restored. The country's water minister has clearly said that a binding guarantee is a priority in renewal talks.

According to Dhaka, a formula based on actual availability -- like the present one -- is very bad for Bangladesh during declines in upstream flow.

India's objections, on the other hand, are based on its own set of factors.

Indian officials hold that any new arrangement needs to take into account India's changing requirements -- including drinking water, irrigation, industrial consumption and thermal power generation.

West Bengal wants enough to keep flowing in the Bhagirathi-Hooghly system, including the needs of navigation and Kolkata Port. Bihar, another key stakeholder, wants a comprehensive relook at Farakka barrage's impact on the flows of its rivers.

This has become a hot-button issue in Bihar, where concerns are rising over Farakka barrange's role in increasing silt, falling river capacity and recurring floods. The JD(U) has even called for India to walk away from the treaty.

The state also argues that its agri and industrial water needs have not received enough attention. External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar has assured Bihar that its drinking-water and industrial requirements will be considered before a decision is taken.

So, the Ganga water discord is no longer limited just to India's water-sharing obligations. It has become a question of balancing a diverse set of factors.

A wider diplomatic tussle

One can't look at the treaty's renewal process without taking into account the current deterioration in India-Bangladesh ties.

The Sheikh Hasina matter, border tiffs, trade issues, visas and connectivity all have contributed to a souring of relations. Dhaka has also been reviewing bilateral arrangements concluded during Hasina's tenure, including agreements involving the use of Chattogram and Mongla ports and connectivity projects, the ToI reported.

Trade restrictions imposed by both countries have added to the friction.

Water diplomacy has taken an additional strategic turn through Bangladesh's engagement with China on the Teesta river. The country is pursuing a comprehensive river-management and restoration project with China's help.

While China insists the arrangement doesn't target any third country, its track-record has hardly inspired confidence in India. That the Teesta basin lies close to the Siliguri Corridor -- also known as the Chicken's neck -- has stoked more worries.

India is keen to keep the matter bilateral. Bangladesh, meanwhile, is willing to take the issue global. The possibility of Chinese involvement therefore has made matters more complex and sensitive, an earlier ET report had said.

What happens if the December 12 deadline is missed?

The immediate danger is a legal and operational vacuum. The treaty has a 30-year term and does not provide for automatic renewal. Unless both governments agree to extend it or negotiate a successor arrangement, the existing allocation formula and its treaty-specific guarantees will cease to apply after December 12.

This would leave the two countries approaching the next lean season without the certainty of an agreed schedule for water sharing.

Bangladesh could also take the matter global to strengthen its case. There is a limit to what it can do, though. Unlike the Indus Waters Treaty between India and Pakistan, the Ganga pact does not provide for a neutral expert or a court of arbitration to adjudicate unresolved cases.

Under the Ganga pact, the dispute-resolution process goes from the bilateral Joint Committee to the Joint Rivers Commission and, ultimately, consultations between the two governments.

Internationalising the dispute could generate diplomatic pressure, but it would not automatically create a binding mechanism for getting more water for anyone.

An interim arrangement might offer a practical way out. Rather than allowing the treaty to lapse while negotiating a wholly new agreement, the two governments could mutually agree to extend the existing formula for a shorter period, possibly one or two years.

That would preserve the current arrangements while giving technical experts time to examine revised allocations, minimum-flow guarantees and the concerns of all sides.

Also read | Trump-Xi-Putin summit: Can the three find common ground on war, oil, nukes?

Such a temporary extension has also been suggested in diplomatic talks in Bangladesh. India is considering a shorter tenure as part of the options for a revised agreement, ET reported.

Updated hydrological assessments, changing rainfall patterns, climate risks, siltation and the water requirements of downstream communities must inform the revised formula, ET's report said.

Under the current arrangement, a Joint Committee monitors water flows at Farakka and Hardinge Bridge. Disagreements can be escalated through the Joint Rivers Commission. But this can't alone cannot settle a question that now requires political agreement at the highest level.

India's position on renewal of the treaty has also been also linked to a possible visit by Bangladesh Prime Minister Tarique Rahman. The visit, if it happens, could provide a big opportunity for PM Modi and Rahman to put bilateral ties, alongside the Ganga matter, on track again.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › India › India, Bangladesh stare at rough waters as a critical deadline approaches
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+