How real is an impartial broker?
Companies can now float both broking and insurance businesses.
On the face of it, IRDA���s stance marks a breakthrough. Earlier, the regulator had disallowed banks which participate in insurance joint ventures from selling insurance policies of other companies. Many banks were unhappy with this restriction because there were fat fees to be earned from broking.
Also in the case of mutual funds, banks are already selling products of multiple companies. Even banks with MF subsidiaries were selling units of third-party MFs.
While IRDA���s recent decision may encourage many financial conglomerates to promote an insurance broking company for distribution, bank branches are unlikely to be able to sell products of multiple insurance companies. This is because the only way banks are allowed to actively sell insurance products is by acquiring a corporate agency.
Present norms relating to insurance agents follow the concept of a tied agent where an agent can represent only one company. This concept applied to both an individual agent as well as a tied agent.
The objective behind this concept is to ensure that there is a sense of responsibility towards the agent and also to ensure that the agent does not sell products of the company that offer him the highest commission.
While banks can become corporate agents, they cannot become brokers. The only way a bank can get into the broking business is by floating a subsidiary with the prescribed capital with same FDI limits as an insurance company.
Even after floating a broking arm, a bank branch still cannot sell products because the IRDA prescribes that only employees of the broking firm can do the distribution work.
Coming back to the issue of promoters having a broking and an insurance arm, this is an accepted practice worldwide.
Internationally, in many jurisdictions there is no prohibition with regard to the group owning insurance companies promoting broking companies.
In fact, in all the broking scandals that have broken out globally, the issue really was the broker pushing products of the insurance company that offers maximum commission. Therefore, independence of a broker is no guarantee that he will ensure the best interest of the consumer.
However, to ensure that there is no partiality towards group companies, IRDA has put in obligations for insurance companies dealing with group broking companies and vice versa. This includes conditions that group companies will not get more favourable terms or higher commission than others.
Also insurance companies cannot design special insurance products for sale exclusively through the broker.
The broker also has to ensure that not more than 25% of the insurance handled by it is placed with the group insurance company.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.