Why India will be watching Trump in Manila and Shenzhen

US President Donald Trump’s participation in the Quad summit in Manila, followed by meetings with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, could test Washington’s commitment to its Asian partners. The Quad mee...

ET Online

US President Donald Trump and Prime Minister Narendra Modi face a crucial test of the Quad as Trump prepares to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. (AI-generated image)

US President Donald Trump’s Asian tour this week may present an unusual diplomatic paradox of sorts. On November 17, the US President will join the leaders of India, Japan and Australia in Manila, Philippines, for a meeting of Quad, a grouping often seen as a counter-balance to China in the Indo-Pacific region. This will be the grouping’s first leaders-level engagement in more than two years. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has already reached Manila.

The significance of Trump's Manila visit lies not simply in the expected revival of the Quad but in what Trump does immediately afterwards.

ALSO READ | PM Modi arrives in Philippines for ASEAN, East Asia summits; eyes stronger regional ties


From Manila, Trump will fly to Shenzhen in China where he will hold a bilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping, besides holding a trilateral with both Xi and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen.

Trump's talks with Xi will indicate whether he still sees the Quad as a strategic commitment or increasingly as one more instrument in its negotiations with China.

The Quad returns
ADVERTISEMENT

The Manila meeting is important because the Quad has struggled to maintain its leaders-level momentum. Since its first leaders' summit in 2021, the grouping held six such meetings, with the last one taking place in September 2024. India's turn to host the next summit in 2025 did not materialise despite repeated postponements. The reason was Trump's transactional diplomacy where he appeared to treat allies and rivals equally.

ALSO READ | Modi, Trump to attend first Quad leaders' meeting in two years on sidelines of ASEAN Summit in Manila

This interruption raised questions about America's commitment to the grouping under Trump. His preference for bilateral negotiations and transactional diplomacy appeared at odds with the Quad's broader agenda of building a regional balance through sustained cooperation.

The concerns were not entirely misplaced. Trump has pursued direct engagement with Xi even as the US and China remain strategic competitors. For India and other Quad countries, this creates an uncomfortable possibility that the US could seek a temporary accommodation with China without adequately considering the concerns of its Asian partners.
ADVERTISEMENT

The renaming of the US Indo-Pacific Command back to US Pacific Command in June 2026 added to the unease. The original designation had been changed in 2018 to reflect the growing strategic importance of the Indian Ocean and the wider Indo-Pacific. The Pentagon, however, maintained that the command's geographical responsibilities and military mission remained unchanged. However, the name change was politically significant.

Manila is about more than reassuring allies
ADVERTISEMENT

The immediate question in Manila will be what concrete outcomes the four countries can deliver after the long gap. The meeting is expected to focus on economic security, critical technologies, strategic infrastructure and maritime cooperation.

The four countries are reportedly working on initiatives that could involve critical technologies, economic security and strategic infrastructure. Critical minerals could also feature prominently. Leaders might also discuss protecting commercial shipping lanes and securing global energy supplies.

China dominates several critical mineral processing and manufacturing supply chains. Reducing this dependence is increasingly important as India expands its electronics, semiconductor and clean energy industries.

Maritime security is equally significant. China's expanding naval presence in the Indian Ocean and its activities around the South China Sea have made closer coordination between the four Quad members strategically valuable. The Philippines, which has faced repeated maritime confrontations with Chinese vessels, provides an especially relevant setting for these discussions. There is also an important diplomatic signal in the fact that the US is hosting the meeting.

The Shenzhen meeting

The timing of Trump's China engagement makes the Manila meeting particularly important. On November 19, Trump, Xi and Putin are scheduled to hold their first trilateral meeting in Shenzhen. China confirmed the arrangement on November 16, following earlier confirmations from the US and Russia. The discussions are expected to include nuclear arms reduction and strategic stability, although the full agenda remains unclear.

The gathering is significant because it brings together three countries with enormous military capabilities and competing geopolitical interests. It also creates a new diplomatic format in which India will have no seat.

For India, the concern is not necessarily that the US and China will reach a grand bargain but the more immediate concern could be that Trump might make concessions on issues important to China in return for economic or political gains elsewhere.

Taiwan is one such issue. Any change in the American position on arms sales or security support to Taiwan would have consequences for the wider Asian balance of power. Technology restrictions and China's dominance of critical mineral supply chains are other areas where a US-China understanding could affect India's strategic calculations.

The experience of Trump's September meeting with Xi in Washington offers some clues. The two sides extended their trade truce by two months, while several major disagreements remained unresolved. The US also paused a proposed $14-billion arms sale to Taiwan amid Chinese pressure.

More importantly for India, the temporary trade understanding raised questions about Trump's willingness to apply economic pressure on China while maintaining pressure on India over Russian oil purchases.

After Trump came to power the second time, tariffs, disagreements over Russian crude purchases and America's engagement with Pakistan's military complicated bilateral ties. India was also exposed to the threat of additional American tariffs linked to its purchases of Russian energy.

The September US-China understanding made this problem more visible. China secured temporary trade relief even as India remained vulnerable to American pressure over Russian oil.

India does not necessarily object to America engaging China as India itself engages with China for better economic ties. The US and China have economic interests that cannot simply be wished away. But India could be watching whether Trump applies different standards to China and India.

The Quad can become Trump's bargaining instrument

There is little reason to assume that Trump sees the Quad in exactly the same way as India, Japan and Australia. For India and other members, the grouping is a long-term strategic arrangement that helps maintain a favourable balance of power in the Indo-Pacific without becoming a formal military alliance. For the US, it can also serve as leverage in its dealings with China.

The sequencing of the two meetings is therefore important. Trump will meet America's Asian partners before sitting down with Xi. Trump's effort to revive Quad can give him a bargaining chip in dealing with China.

India, Japan and Australia would want the Manila meeting to produce practical commitments rather than another declaration about a free and open Indo-Pacific, as could be the case if Trump merely uses Manila meet as a projection.

What it means for India

India's aim could be to preserve the Quad without becoming overly dependent on America's strategic calculations. The grouping's value lies partly in its ability to bring together four major Indo-Pacific democracies with complementary strengths. Japan contributes technological and industrial capabilities. Australia offers strategic depth and access to critical minerals. The US brings military reach and advanced defence technology. India provides geographical depth in the Indian Ocean and a significant regional presence. This combination cannot easily be replaced by bilateral arrangements.

However, India recognises the limits of the Quad. It is not a collective defence arrangement and cannot guarantee that the US will always align its China policy with Indian interests. The Shenzhen meeting will test this idea. If Trump pursues a limited understanding with Xi, it would indicate American strategic priorities do not automatically coincide with the Quad's.

The real takeaway from Manila, therefore, will not be whether Trump has revived the Quad but whether the grouping can remain useful even when the Trump is simultaneously negotiating with China.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Defence › Why India will be watching Trump in Manila and Shenzhen
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+