Asim Munir wants to chop Pakistan into pieces to weaken Bhuttos & Sharifs, give military more power
Pakistan's proposal to create smaller provinces could have far-reaching political, financial and strategic implications, according to strategic affairs analyst Sushant Sareen. Speaking to TOI, he argued that the military establishment could use th...

Asim Munir
Speaking in an interview with TOI on the Faultline show on the Times Axis YouTube channel, Sareen said the proposed division of larger provinces could make it harder for established political parties to challenge the military's authority.
"It's not an army. It's a political party. It's like the Communist Party of China," he said, describing the military's growing role in Pakistan's political affairs.
Read more - Muzaffarnagar men hid 1 kg gold paste inside knee caps: Police smell something fishy during vehicle check, bust Saudi Arabia-linked smuggling racket
Pakistan's smaller provinces plan: Why the military could benefit
Sareen believes the proposed restructuring could significantly alter the political balance in Pakistan, particularly in Sindh and Punjab, where the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) and Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) have traditionally wielded considerable influence.He argued that dividing existing provinces could break up the political strongholds of these parties and create smaller administrative units with new centres of power.
Read more - India’s largest pumped hydro project in Mandsaur: Rs 11,474 crore plant will reuse same water again & again to generate 1,920 MW electricity
Karachi's possible separation from Sindh, for instance, could weaken the PPP's influence, according to Sareen.
"If People's Party loses Karachi, there's no point running Sindh because Sindh without Karachi is nothing," he said.
Punjab could also see a similar political shift. Sareen suggested that creating smaller provinces would open up opportunities for regional leaders to become chief ministers instead of remaining provincial legislators or ministers in a much larger political unit.
"It's better to become the chief minister of a smaller part of Punjab than be just a member of the provincial assembly or a minister in Punjab," he said.
In his assessment, such changes could weaken established political dynasties while making regional leadership more dependent on the military establishment.
Mohsin Naqvi's referendum suggestion raises questions over Pakistan's provinces
Pakistan's Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has floated the idea of holding a referendum on the proposal to create smaller provinces.However, Sareen questioned whether a referendum could be used to bypass the constitutional procedures required for creating new provinces.
He argued that the proposed restructuring was not emerging from a broad-based political or administrative process but was being driven by the country's powerful military establishment.
"This is by diktat of a dictator, or a quasi-dictator, or an undeclared dictator," he said.
Sareen also cautioned that changing provincial boundaries could trigger political resistance, administrative uncertainty and further instability.
Taking a swipe at the possible consequences of the military's approach, he said: "If Asim Munir wants to be the Gorbachev of Pakistan, I'm the last person to stop him from doing that."
Balochistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa minerals: Is control over resources another motive?
Beyond political calculations, Sareen pointed to Pakistan's mineral wealth as another possible reason behind the proposed provincial restructuring.He suggested that greater control over resource-rich regions such as Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa could be an important consideration for the military establishment.
The analyst also raised concerns about the existing financial arrangement between the federal government and provinces.
Under the current revenue-sharing framework, provinces receive around 57% of the divisible pool. Sareen argued that the federal government already controls a substantial share of the country's overall resources, but suggested that the military's financial interests could be driving demands for a greater share. "Greed has no limit," he said.
His argument is that the proposed restructuring could have implications not only for political representation but also for the distribution and control of Pakistan's natural resources and public finances.
Why India's security establishment should watch Pakistan's proposed restructuring
The possibility of smaller provinces also raises questions about whether reorganising Pakistan would make the country more stable.Sareen expressed doubts about that outcome. He argued that instability in Pakistan could work in India's favour, but only if it remained limited and manageable.
"Instability in Pakistan is very good for us, but provided it's a controlled instability," he said.
He warned that an uncontrolled crisis in Pakistan, a country with a population of around 250 million, could create serious challenges for India.
Inputs from TOI
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.