GST on corporate guarantees: Delhi HC strikes down 1% minimum valuation rule as arbitrary
The Delhi High Court has ruled that corporate guarantees furnished by holding companies for subsidiaries attract GST even when no consideration is charged. However, it struck down the mandatory 1% annual valuation floor under Rule 28(2) as arbitra...

The issue raised by various companies including Sterlite Power Transmission, Jindal Stainless, Essar Power, GAIL (India), Essar Shipping, Future Brands, Hero Future Energies, Hero Solar Energy and others, was whether the issuance of a corporate guarantee by a holding/parent company in favour of a financial institution, in respect of the financial obligations of its subsidiary/group company, constitutes a supply and/or supply of service under Sections 7 and 9 of CGST, consequently making it a taxable event attracting the imposition of GST at the rate of 1% under Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules 2017.
The division bench comprising Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar held that the corporate guarantee is not excluded from the levy, either as an actionable claim under Entry 6 of Schedule III, or as a security under Section 2(102) of the 2017 Act.
The amount a subsidiary receives from the holding company is credit support, and not a claim, it said, adding that the subsidiary acquires no right against the guarantor under the guarantee. On the contrary, if the guarantor makes payment, the subsidiary becomes its debtor, and not its creditor, it ruled.
According to the court, the service lies in the assumption of the risk of the related person's default, and the resulting extension of the guarantor's credit worthiness to it and the recipient of the service is the related person/subsidiary on whose behalf the guarantee is furnished, under Section 2(93)(c) of the 2017 Act.
The court said that Rule 28(2) prescribes the valuation of supply for corporate guarantees provided between related persons is not beyond Article 246A or Article 265 of the Constitution. "However, insofar as it makes the deemed value of 1% per annum a fixed minimum which cannot be displaced, it is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. Therefore, Rule 28(2) is read down," the judgment stated.
Therefore, the deemed value shall give way to a lower open market value, where the supplier establishes such value on cogent and verifiable material, it said. "However, the consideration agreed between the related persons, or the absence of any consideration, shall not by itself constitute such material. The proviso to Rule 28(2) is valid," the court held, while setting aside the show cause notices, orders and demands raised against the companies to the extent they proceed on a basis contrary to the findings recorded by it.
The HC further said that the tax is to be computed at the time of supply for the entire tenure of the guarantee, though it is open to the tax authorities to provide for its collection in annual instalments. "Guarantees executed before July 1, 2017 are not taxable, unless they are renewed, extended or enhanced thereafter. Guarantees executed between July 1, 2017 and October 25, 2023 are taxable but are to be valued under the Rules then in force, without recourse to Rule 28(2) or to the figure of 1% as a uniform measure. Rule 28(2) applies only to guarantees executed, renewed, extended or enhanced on or after October 26,2023, it clarified.
The proper officers shall determine the liability afresh, if any, in accordance with the Tuesday's judgment, after giving the companies an adequate opportunity of hearing, the court directed.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.