Silver ETFs crash over 56% from January peak. Should investors buy, hold or exit?

Since January 2026, silver ETFs have seen a remarkable 56% plummet, stirring unrest among investors about their holdings. Experts link this downturn to profit-taking, a robust US dollar, and heightening interest rates. While some advisors recommen...

ET Online
Silver ETFs have witnessed a sharp correction, falling over 56% from their peak on January 29, 2026, leaving investors who entered near the highs with steep losses. The decline has followed a strong rally in silver prices and has raised questions about whether the investors should buy, hold or exit.

Market experts say that the correction has been driven by several factors, including profit-booking after the sharp rally, a stronger US dollar, higher interest rates and bond yields, and concerns over industrial demand. With silver prices now significantly lower, investors are assessing whether this is an opportunity to accumulate the metal or a warning to stay away.

Vishal Dhawan, Founder and CEO of Plan Ahead Wealth Advisors told ETMutualFunds that a drop of over 56% shows that silver is far more volatile than other assets because its price depends on both factory orders and investor mood; when global growth slows or traders pull back, silver tends to fall more than other assets and investors should view this drop as a reminder of silver's natural price swings rather than a flaw in the asset.


Also Read | MF Tracker: Invesco India Midcap Fund tops 3-year equity fund returns with 22%. Should investors invest now?

Dhawan says investors should avoid panic-selling, particularly if silver forms only a small part of their portfolio and they have the time to remain invested. However, adding large amounts simply to bring down the average purchase price could be risky, as prices have not yet stabilised.

He suggests accumulating silver in small amounts over several months rather than making large investments at once. Investors should also keep their overall silver allocation limited to around 5-10% of their portfolio to protect their wealth from further price swings.
ADVERTISEMENT

Rajesh Minocha, a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) and Founder of Financial Radiance shared with ETMutualFunds that selling during the current market dip should not be the primary response for every silver investor, particularly if there is no better alternative available. However, he cautions that further losses are possible and investors should not rush to buy more without carefully evaluating their exposure.

He advises investors to assess their silver holdings as part of their overall portfolio and ensure that the allocation does not exceed an appropriate level. His investment preference is multi-asset funds, where professional fund managers allocate money across debt, equity and commodities such as gold and silver based on their market outlook.

According to the data by ACE MF, the silver ETFs on an average lost 56.47% from January 29, 2026 to November 19, 2026. There were nearly 17 silver ETFs in the said time period.

Out of these 17 silver ETFs, Tata Silver ETF lost the most of around 56.77% in the said time period. This was followed by the DSP Silver ETF that lost 56.77% in the same time period.
ADVERTISEMENT

Nippon India Silver ETF, the largest fund in the category based on assets managed, lost 56.5% since January 29, 2026. Zerodha CASE Silver ETF lost the lowest of around 55.60% in the same time period.

What has triggered such a sharp correction?

Minocha said that silver has fallen sharply because of several factors, including profit-taking, a reversal in speculation, a stronger US Dollar, higher bond yields, and higher interest rates.
ADVERTISEMENT

Before these recent sharp losses, the silver rally had greatly exceeded the market’s economic fundamentals. Although the industrial demand case remains, the other factors have dominated this sharp reversal, he further said.

Dhawan said that silver fell after rising and peaking in January 2026, which led many investors to sell and lock in profits. Meanwhile, high interest rates and a stronger dollar made silver less appealing to buyers. Slower factory demand and using less silver added downward pressure.

“This fall is largely a cooling-off period after a price surge rather than a complete breakdown in silver's value. When prices climb too quickly, sharp drops often follow to bring prices back to normal levels. Even so, the immediate excitement has faded, and prices may take time to settle before climbing again.”

However, Dhawan believes silver's long-term fundamentals remain supported by demand from clean energy, electronics and electric vehicles. Global silver supply also remains tight, which could support prices over several years. Investors should, however, expect steadier and more modest growth rather than a repeat of the rapid rally witnessed before the correction.

Also Read | Quant Mid Cap Fund increases stake in Persistent Systems, IDBI Bank and 1 other stock in October

Historical performance

In January 2026, precious metals rose sharply due to global uncertainty, changing currency trends, and growing demand for safe assets which led to investors buying precious metals as protection against market risks, pushing prices to very high levels.

Despite a hefty correction in the last two trading sessions of the month, silver surged nearly 19%. Silver reached very high levels, close to record prices in January. On January 29, silver futures scaled fresh lifetime highs on the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX), silver surged past the Rs 4 lakh mark for the first time.

Silver emerged better than gold in the starting month of the current calendar year because it benefits both as a precious metal and from industrial demand, which added to the buying pressure.

However, towards the end of the month, things changed quickly. Once prices became very high, many investors started selling to book profits. This caused a sudden fall in prices. On January 30, silver delivered a stunning reversal on the MCX, plunging up to 27% — or Rs 1,07,968 — in a single day, marking its worst-ever crash and dragging prices back below the Rs 3 lakh mark, just a day after the metal had surged to a record high of Rs 4 lakh.

The fall on January 31, silver delivered a stunning reversal on MCX, plunging up to 25% — or Rs 92,000 — in a single day, marking its worst crash in 15 years and dragging prices back below the Rs 3 lakh mark, just a day after the metal had soared to a record high of Rs 4 lakh.

Time to focus on silver ETFs?

The sharp correction has brought silver ETF prices significantly below their January peak, potentially attracting investors looking to enter at lower levels. However, with prices still volatile and the possibility of further declines, deciding when and how much to invest remains important.

Dhawan said that new investors can consider the lower prices as a more measured entry point after the earlier market excitement has faded. However, he recommends spreading investments across smaller, regular purchases instead of committing a lump sum.

According to him, regular monthly investments can help investors accumulate more units when prices fall and reduce the pressure of trying to identify the market bottom. He suggests setting up a monthly investment plan over 12 months and maintaining a calm, long-term approach rather than expecting quick gains.

Minocha said that the best strategy for silver investment should not involve lump-sum purchases. Instead, investing over 3–6 months can lower timing risks. Silver should not be a main investment; it should make up 5% of the total investment.

How did their counterparts perform?

In the same time period, gold ETFs on an average lost 24.86%, an analysis by ETMutualFunds showed. There were 25 gold ETFs, of which Nippon India ETF Gold BeES lost the most of around 25.45% and LIC MF Gold ETF lost the lowest of around 22.94% in the same time period.

Also Read | DSP Mutual Fund turns bullish on gold and silver, begins systematic buying

Silver ETFs: In the current calendar year so far, silver ETFs are down 28.26% on an average. In the last three months and six months, silver ETFs on an average lost 29.24% and 38.21% respectively. In the last three years, silver ETFs on an average gave 29.12% returns.

Should investors prefer gold ETFs over silver ETFs after the correction?

The difference highlights the relatively higher volatility of silver and raises questions about whether investors should favour gold for a larger share of their precious metals allocation.

Minocha said gold has much less volatility than silver because silver has strong industrial demand, so for most investors, gold is a more stable option for a larger share of precious-metals investments. Silver will continue to depend on US Dollar movements, the economy and demand for industrial use for goods such as electric vehicles.

He further said that gold will likely continue to outperform silver because it is less volatile, despite silver’s demand, particularly from the solar industry. In addition, silver demand exceeds available supply, and the Silver Institute expects this imbalance to continue to create supply deficits through 2026.

Dhawan said gold offers better protection during uncertain market conditions. Central banks regularly buy gold as a reserve asset, which helps support its demand and makes it relatively more stable than silver.

“For most everyday investors, keeping a larger share in gold ETFs, such as 70% to 80% of the metal allocation, offers a safer approach. Over the next six to twelve months, silver prices will closely follow interest rates and the strength of the US dollar. If the central banks start cutting rates and the dollar weakens, silver prices usually get a strong lift. A recovery in global manufacturing will also play a major role in reviving demand.”

He further said that demand from solar energy projects, electronics makers, and seasonal jewellery buying will also guide silver over the coming year. Changes in the rupee's value against the dollar and government rules on import taxes affect local silver prices.

(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)

If you have any mutual fund queries, message ET Mutual Funds on Facebook/Twitter. We will get them answered by our panel of experts. Do share your questions at ETMFqueries@timesinternet.in along with your age, risk profile, and Twitter handle
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

Top Mutual Funds

3 M(%)
6 M(%)
1 YR(%)
3 YRS(%)

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

Save with Tax planning SIP's

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Mutual Funds › Analysis › Silver ETFs crash over 56% from January peak. Should investors buy, hold or exit?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+