NFO Insight: Carnelian Small Cap Fund opens for subscription with Rs 5,000 crore size cap. Can it deliver alpha?

Market veteran Vikas Khemani’s Carnelian Mutual Fund has launched Carnelian Small Cap Fund which is open for subscription and will close on October 30. This small cap fund will follow QGARP as the investment philosophy which means quality growth at a reasonable price and is built on two pillars.

The fund will follow a focused, research-led investment approach guided by Carnelian’s philosophy of Clarity, Conviction and Compounding. It will seek to identify businesses with sustainable earnings growth, durable competitive advantages and attractive risk-reward characteristics, while remaining disciplined on valuations.

What does the fund house say on this small cap fund?

Vikas Khemani, Founder & Chairman: Our investment philosophy of Carnelian as a group rests on three principles: clarity in understanding businesses, conviction in our investment decisions and a long-term perspective on compounding. Our approach combines fundamental research, forensic financial analysis and ground-level validation to evaluate both potential upside and risks The objective is to identify businesses where fundamentals and valuations support a compelling investment case.


Also Read | JioBlackRock Flexi Cap Fund exits Eternal, Ashok Leyland and 16 more, trims stake in RIL, HDFC Bank and 32 others

Rajkumar Dhiman, CEO: Small-cap investing offers a broad opportunity set, but demands discipline in evaluating businesses and constructing portfolios. Our structured process combines quantitative screening, forensic diligence and ground-level assessment of management and business fundamentals. We believe alpha, not AUM, is what ultimately matters to investors. The cap keeps the portfolio nimble and our process disciplined as the scheme grows. Our focus is on generating alpha from the quality of opportunities we identify, not on the size of the assets we gather.

What does an expert say - Can Carnelian’s Rs 5,000 crore cap help generate alpha?

Protima Dhawan, Director & Unit Head, Anand Rathi Wealth Limited told ETMutualFunds that The Rs 5,000 crore cap aims to keep Carnelian flexible, as small-cap stocks have lower trading volumes. Large trades by oversized funds can move stock prices, making it harder to enter or exit investments at desired prices.

Dhawan further said that the cap is also to avoid buying weaker companies simply to deploy excess money and instead remain focused on its strongest investment ideas, the goal is to hold a basket of 30-50 stocks, selected by thorough research and emphasis on business quality and growth. Overall, the objective remains to beat the benchmark of Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI.

Shruti Jain, CSO, Arihant Capital shared with ETMutualFunds that according to her this rigid capacity cap is a highly necessary structural adjustment in today's small-cap landscape. In this domain, an excessive asset base can easily become a major detriment to overall portfolio performance.

Jain further said that when asset sizes expand rapidly, the massive influx of capital forces fund managers into lower-conviction ideas or larger, less agile companies just to maintain capital deployment, by hard-capping the fund early at Rs 5,000 crore, the portfolio preserves optimal execution agility so this flexibility allows the management to build or exit core positions efficiently without triggering adverse price movements, shifting the operational focus entirely toward pure performance.

What is Rs 5,000 crore cap?

The fund house said that the cap is intended to preserve agility in portfolio construction and enable the investment team to remain selective as the fund grows, prioritizing investment opportunities over asset gathering.

According to the scheme information document, once the scheme’s AUM reaches Rs 5,000 crore, the scheme will accept only SIP inflows, including both existing and new SIP registrations. The fund house further mentioned that it plans to stop accepting fresh lumpsum investments, including switch-ins and STP transactions, from the third business day after the limit is reached. Existing and new SIP registrations can continue.

Can forensic research uncover small-cap risks and opportunities?

Jain said that capping capacity early serves as an essential performance shield, once the fund nears its limit, it will restrict fresh lump-sum inflows to prevent the portfolio from exceeding its optimal size which protects existing investors from high impact costs and forced capital deployment in an illiquid market and to mitigate the severe capital impairment caused by governance failures, the fund deploys Carnelian’s institutional CLEAR framework.

This forensic filter ensures paper profits convert 100% into operating cash, dissects balance sheets for hidden debt, and scrutinises subsidiary transaction loops to intercept financial engineering early and combined with ground-level channel checks, we view this as a highly sophisticated mechanism to secure durable wealth creators.

Also Read | Silver ETFs fall up to 5% as high oil prices weigh on sentiment. What should investors do?

While mentioning the SIP and lumpsum investment conditions, Dhawan said that along with the capacity limit, the fund house also will use two research frameworks to evaluate companies for investment which include CLEAR, which would look into the health of companies, and CONNECT, which would look into the management and any stakeholders involved.

According to a note by a fund house, Indian equities witnessed a broad-based correction in September, with the Nifty 50 falling 6.1%, the Nifty Midcap 100 declining 7.6%, and the Nifty Smallcap 100 down 3.4%, amid higher crude prices, rising global yields, inflation concerns and geopolitical uncertainty.

The correction has improved valuations in some areas, particularly large caps, but mid- and small-cap valuations remain elevated, with mid-caps trading at a 52% premium to the Nifty and small caps at a record 30% premium at September-end.

Time to enter small caps?

Dhawan said we are currently seeing a lot of ups and downs in the market. If we look at valuations, we can see that overall, the market is seeing negative froth, with small caps trading around 18% below their estimated fair value. Hence this could serve as a good entry point for investors.

At the same time, investors need to remember that small caps can go through periods of sharp ups and downs. Over the last 20 years, the Nifty Smallcap 250 has seen an average drawdown of around 25%, with most corrections lasting around three to four months. Markets generally recover to their previous peaks within 12 to 18 months, showing recovery usually comes but requires patience and discipline, Dhawan further said.

Jain said valuations across the broader small-cap universe are demanding, with the Nifty Smallcap 250 index currently trading at an extended trailing P/E of around 34 times, which sits comfortably above historical averages and Entering during an elevated market cycle naturally increases near-term entry risk, making an explicit focus on corporate governance and quality screening non-negotiable.

She further advised investors to completely bypass aggressive lump sums for fresh allocations into this NFO today and instead build exposure sequentially through a disciplined SIP strategy, a structured, long-term entry route that we strongly advocate.

At the time of receiving the approval from Sebi for launching mutual fund business, the fund house said with the approval to launch its mutual fund business, Carnelian will now be able to expand its investment offerings to a wider investor base while building on its existing presence across PMS, AIFs and offshore investment strategies.

Carnelian Mutual Fund vs PMS, AIFs: What’s Different?

Jain said while the fund’s foundational philosophy of "quality growth at a reasonable price" and forensic screening remains identical across all platforms, the vehicle dictates the structure, the PMS and AIF strategies often run highly concentrated, customised mandates suited for institutional money. This mutual fund NFO, however, democratises that institutional capability for a wider retail audience.

Also Read | Mutual funds increase cash holdings by Rs 87 crore to Rs 1.83 lakh crore in September, cash allocation rises to nearly 4%

To manage daily liquidity efficiently within the mutual fund framework, the portfolio will be slightly more diversified, yet it will strictly retain the core, research-backed investment framework that defines the investment house, a structural balance that we believe successfully bridges institutional capability with retail market accessibility, Jain further said.

Dhawan said that Carnelian’s existing PMS, AIF and offshore strategies follow different approaches, including multi-cap investing, structural themes and contra investing. The Small Cap Fund will focus specifically on small cap companies, with a Rs 5,000 crore cap to maintain flexibility. It will also use Carnelian’s forensic research process to find quality small cap stocks with strong growth potential at reasonable valuations.

Way ahead for small caps?

In the last three years, the small caps delivered an average return of 13.71% with Bandhan Small Cap Fund delivering the highest return of 21.25% in the same period. HDFC Small Cap Fund gave the lowest return of 8.51% in the last three years.

In the last five years, the small cap funds gave an average return of 13.35% with Bank of India Small Cap Fund delivering the highest return of 16.81% and PGIM India Small Cap Fund delivering the lowest return of around 9.39% in the same time period.

Dhawan said that the long term outlook for small caps is positive. If we look at Nifty Smallcap 250, we can see that earnings are expected to grow by around 27% in FY27 and 33% in FY28, which gives some support to the segment even after the strong rally we have seen.

The main takeaway is that investors should not change their allocation based on short term market movements or the recent rally. They should maintain a balanced exposure of around 55% in large caps, 23% in mid caps and 22% in small caps, to capture stability as well as growth potential. If they have funds available, they should go ahead and invest it as lumpsum. Those doing SIPs can continue, Dhawan further said.

(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)

If you have any mutual fund queries, message ET Mutual Funds on Facebook/Twitter. We will get them answered by our panel of experts. Do share your questions at ETMFqueries@timesinternet.in along with your age, risk profile, and Twitter handle