How three-year FMPs still score over fixed deposits

After the budget changed the rules for non-equity mutual funds, several fund houses junked their plans to launch one- and two-year FMPs. Some even returned to investors the money collected during recently closed NFOs of oneyear schemes.

These have now been replaced by 3-year FMPs on the market shelves. At least seven 3-year FMPs are currently on offer (see table) and more are in the pipeline.

Experts say that given the high bond yields, one can expect a pre-tax yield of over 9% from these FMPs. Given that you can claim indexation benefit on these schemes after three years, the tax will be significantly lower compared to what is payable on the interest earned on fixed deposits.

“The budget killed 1-2 year FMPs but 3-year FMPs still have a significant tax advantage over fixed deposits,” says a senior fund manager.

The interest on fixed deposits is fully taxable. It is added to the income of the investor and taxed as normal income. For those with a taxable income of over rs 10 lakh a year, the tax is 30%. In stark comparison, the effective tax on the gains from a 3-year FMP is less than 4% if you assume a modest inflation of 8% (see table).


Poor on liquidity

Though FMPs can give higher post-tax returns, they don’t score very well on the liquidity front. They are closed-ended schemes and the fund house is not under any obligation to redeem the units before the maturity date.

However, mutual funds do offer a small exit window to investors who want to redeem before maturity. FMPs are listed on the stocks exchanges and one can sell his investments to anyone willing to buy it. But this exit route is only a theoretical possibility. In reality, there are hardly any FMPs traded on the exchanges.



According to Value Research, during 2013, only eight of the 700 FMPs available in the market were traded on the BSE on 20 days. This year has been better but the volumes rarely cross a few hundred FMP transactions in a day. The scanty trading is not the only problem. The price offered by buyers is usually lower than the NAV of the scheme. If you need the money urgently, you will have to take a loss and sell at a discount. So, be ready to hold for the full term when you invest in an FMP because there is no way you can exit before maturity.