We might be repeating the mistakes of the 1999 bubble and crash

The current market environment is looking a whole lot like the 1998-1999 stock market bubble, and the crash of 2000 may not be far behind.

We might be repeating the mistakes of the 1999 bubble and crash
The stock market may be in danger of repeating some very bad history.

The current market environment is looking a whole lot like the 1998-1999 stock market bubble, and the crash of 2000 may not be far behind, said Michael Hartnett of Bank of America Merrill Lynch.

"It could simply be 1998/99 all over again. After all, a 'speculative blow-off' in asset prices is one logical conclusion to a world dominated by central bank liquidity, technological disruption & wealth inequality," he wrote in a note Sunday.

Hartnett, BAML's chief investment strategist, thinks the emerging market problems and subsequent global response reflect a similar set of circumstances in the late 1990s.

Here's the chain of events via Hartnett (emphasis added):

Back then, as could be the case today, a bull market & a US-led economic recovery was rudely interrupted by a crisis in Emerging Markets. The crisis threatened to hurt Main Street via Wall Street (the Nasdaq fell 33% between Jul-Oct 1998, when [Long-Term Capital Management] went under). Policy makers panicked and monetary policy was eased (with hindsight unnecessarily). Fresh liquidity combined with apocalyptic investor sentiment very quickly morphed into a violent but narrow equity bull market/bubble in 1998/99, one which ultimately took valuations & interest rates sharply higher to levels that eventually caused a "pop".
ADVERTISEMENT

Let's recreate that with today's news.

China slowdown fears sparked a serious drop in both emerging market equities and economic growth.

The stock market went through two big sell-offs in August 2015 and again in December/January/February 2015.

With the Federal Reserve's interest rates already near the zero-bound, there is little room for actual easing. The Fed, however, did hike once and then delayed a possible second hike in March in part due to global fears. The central bank also lowered rate hike expectations, and Chair Janet Yellen has sounded dovish. This coincided to negative interest rate policies around the world.
ADVERTISEMENT

The winter stock market sell-off produced some of the worst investor sentiment in years, and then a stunning comeback has brought indices near all-time highs again.

There are certainly parallels here, and Hartnett highlighted a few things that could happen next which would confirm his "1999 all over again" thesis.
ADVERTISEMENT

"As in 1998/99 post the easing you need to see a. US consumer strengthen in next 6 months, b. US resume tightening in due course, c. lower oil will provoke better macro data; d. M&A, buybacks, IPOs, financial engineering will be positive for stocks; e. worsening market breadth," wrote Hartnett.

Now all of those next steps sound plausible, but there are a few problems here. The emerging market situation is less severe than the late-1990s crisis and, as we mentioned, the Fed has not done actual easing this time around.

This may simply mean that the same situation is playing out, just with slightly less violent consequences. The 1999 tech bubble ended up in a massive drawdown and economic recession. Following the same pattern this time but with better systems in place may simply be a small degree of downside protection, or it could prevent it from happening altogether.

In the end, yes, history may repeat itself, but typically not in exactly the same way. Though it's hard not to see the similarities.
5 midcap stocks to invest in with a 12-month horizon
1/6
Text: By Chiranjivi Chakraborty, ETMarkets.com

The BSE Midcap index has managed quite a turnaround from where things stood on February 29. By that day, the BSE Midcap index had lost 14% of its value for the year compared with a 12% crack in the BSE benchmark Sensex.

Fast forward one month, not only has it managed to rally more than the benchmark (10% compared with a 7% rise in the Sensex), but it has gone from underperforming the 30-pack benchmark to outperforming it.
Text: By Chiranjivi Chakraborty, ETMarkets.com

The BSE Midcap index has managed quite a turnaround from where things stood on February 29. By that day, the BSE Midcap index had lost ..
Read More
Sandeep Raina, deputy VP, Edelweiss Securities

Jamna Auto: “We believe the stock will do well because the commercial vehicle markets are doing well. Second, the company is very much focussing on the after sales because that is the place where Jamna was not there and the company right now is also focusing on financials, they want to have a 30% Return on Capital, they want to focus on dividends, they have a focus on growth rates too,” he said.
Sandeep Raina, deputy VP, Edelweiss Securities

Jamna Auto: “We believe the stock will do well because the commercial vehicle markets are doing well. Second, the company is very much focussing..
Read More
Sandeep Raina, deputy VP, Edelweiss Securities

Indian Terrain: “In last five years, it has grown at close to 30%. I look at the valuation, it is close to 12 times its FY17 earnings. This can be a multibagger in next two-three years,” Raina said.
Sandeep Raina, deputy VP, Edelweiss Securities

Indian Terrain: “In last five years, it has grown at close to 30%. I look at the valuation, it is close to 12 times its FY17 earnings. This can b..
Read More
Sandeep Raina, deputy VP, Edelweiss Securities

Indo Count: Sandeep Raina’s third pick is Indo Count. “The return on capital (ROC) is close to 30-32% which is very high for a normal textile company. The growth is there, market is there, financials are very strong,” he said.

“I think the company can be a multibagger in next two-three years from here on after giving so much fancy returns to the investors,” he said.
Sandeep Raina, deputy VP, Edelweiss Securities Indo Count: Sandeep Raina’s third pick is Indo Count. “The return on capital (ROC) is close to 30-32% which is very high for a normal textile company. ..
Read More
Sandip Sabharwal, asksandipsabharwal.com

Praj Industries: “The company has done well, in the last 10 days of March, they also paid out a dividend of Rs 1.60. Even on dividend yield, it is still at 2%, order booking should be pretty healthy,” said Sandip Sabharwal, asksandipsabharwal.com.

“I think Praj is going to do extremely well. I think in the next two-three years, the growth and improvement in profitability both are going to be quite significant and to that extent, it remains one of my top holdings.”
Sandip Sabharwal, asksandipsabharwal.com

Praj Industries: “The company has done well, in the last 10 days of March, they also paid out a dividend of Rs 1.60. Even on dividend yield, it is stil..
Read More
Prabhudas Lilladher

Heidelberg Cement India: “One of the largest players in the Central region, it has witnessed significant improvement in operations over the past couple of years with the completion of its expansion-cum-modernisation program,” said Prabhudas Lilladher.

“This, coupled with a strong outlook on region’s demand, absence of any fresh capacity addition and exit of weak players like JP Associates, drives our positive outlook on the stock,” he said.
Prabhudas Lilladher Heidelberg Cement India: “One of the largest players in the Central region, it has witnessed significant improvement in operations over the past couple of years with the completi..
Read More
ADVERTISEMENT
READ MORE

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Markets › Stocks › News › We might be repeating the mistakes of the 1999 bubble and crash
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+