Stock market investors vs economists: Nirmala Sitharaman gets contrasting capital gains tax recommendations for Budget 2027
Economists have urged Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to retain the 12.5% equity LTCG tax, countering demands from industry and foreign investors for relief. With FPI outflows mounting, the Budget 2027 decision could have significant implicati...

LTCG tax debate heats up as economists and investors make opposing cases to the Finance Minister.
The disagreement comes as India tries to revive foreign investment after a prolonged selloff. The government must now weigh the potential market and currency benefits of tax relief against the fiscal revenue it would give up and its stated objective of keeping taxation across asset classes broadly aligned.
At the first pre-Budget consultation meeting with economists on Monday, most participants are reported to have advised Sitharaman against reducing the long-term capital-gains tax on equities. “In the meeting, most economists were of the view that there should not be any reduction in Long Term Capital Gains tax,” a PTI report said, quoting a source.
The report said economists believed that “green shoots” were visible in the economy, private investment was beginning to crowd in, and the government’s infrastructure spending was supporting both public and private sector activity.
They also praised the government’s fiscal prudence and lower inflation, while recommending measures to support micro, small and medium enterprises and labour-intensive sectors to create more jobs.
The advice directly counters a rising demand from Dalal Street and industry chambers for the removal of the levy. Global investors have also sought differential treatment for foreign portfolio investors, arguing that LTCG on equities are exempt for foreign investors in several emerging markets.
Also Read | Retain capital gains tax on equities, economists tell FM Sitharaman ahead of Budget 2027-28
What investors want
India currently imposes a 12.5% LTCG tax on listed equities and equity mutual funds when gains exceed Rs 1.25 lakh. The investment must be held for more than 12 months to qualify as a long-term capital asset.Short-term gains on equities sold within 12 months are taxed at 20%.
Industry participants have sought abolition of the LTCG tax or a lower rate for FPIs. Another proposal is to calculate foreign investors’ gains in US-dollar terms, which would provide some indexation benefit against currency movements.
Central Board of Direct Taxes Chairman Ravi Agrawal said Monday that the Finance Ministry was examining various aspects of capital gains taxation on equities and that any changes would be announced in the Union Budget for 2027-28.
Sitharaman herself acknowledged last month that LTCG had become a subject of discussion among domestic and foreign investors. She also said the 2024 changes were aimed at bringing different asset classes “at par” so that investors did not choose one instrument over another purely for tax reasons.
Also Read | $64 billion out, $5 billion in? Why LTCG tax cut may not be enough to bring FIIs back
The fiscal argument
On the other hand, the case for retaining the tax is straightforward because equity LTCG has become a meaningful source of government revenue.Jefferies estimates that equity LTCG collections were Rs 1.3 lakh crore in FY25. Together with securities transaction tax, equity taxation accounted for 8% of direct tax collections and 5% of total gross tax revenue in that year.
SBI Research, however, argues that the headline revenue number needs to be viewed in the context of market performance. The Rs 1.3 lakh crore collection in FY25 coincided with a strong stock market return in the preceding year.
Its model estimates equity LTCG collections at about Rs 1 lakh crore in FY26 and Rs 40,000-50,000 crore in FY27. SBI Research says the government could absorb the potential fiscal shortfall if LTCG were abolished.
The report also suggests alternatives to a complete rollback. These include raising the Rs 1.25 lakh exemption threshold in line with inflation, reducing the tax rate for holdings beyond two or three years, or eliminating LTCG for investments held for more than three years.
Another option would be to increase STT alongside a lower LTCG rate. SBI Research estimates that a 50% increase in STT could generate around Rs 45,000 crore in fiscal 2028.
It also proposes allowing investors to defer LTCG tax when mutual fund redemption proceeds are reinvested in eligible equity mutual funds within 90 days.
Would a tax cut bring back FIIs?
The investor argument is not limited to tax rates. India has experienced a sharp deterioration in foreign ownership and capital flows.Jefferies says total equity market-related exits by FPIs, foreign promoters and foreign private equity investors have reached $110 billion since April 2025. Its analysis of 70 large emerging market funds, with combined assets under management of $380 billion, shows India is underweight by 0.3 percentage points compared with a 10-year average overweight of 2.2 percentage points.
A reduction in equity LTCG could improve sentiment and provide support to the rupee, the brokerage said.
The potential benefit may be most visible in largecaps and sectors that have seen heavy foreign selling. Financials recorded the largest FPI outflows since October 2024 at $16 billion, followed by IT at $10 billion and consumer staples at $10 billion.
Jefferies prefers banks, energy, utilities and real estate among sectors that could benefit from a reversal in foreign flows. It also favours largecaps over midcaps, saying largecaps have underperformed by five percentage points in 2026 and now trade at a 23% valuation discount to their 10-year average.
A recent tax concession for foreign investors in government bonds offers some support for the investor case. Following that relief, debt FPI inflows rose to $9 billion during June and July 2026. An equity LTCG cut could similarly improve sentiment, Jefferies said.
Tax is not the main FPI trigger
A separate analysis by JM Financial, however, suggests that capital gains tax is only a secondary factor in determining foreign flows.FIIs sold $59 billion of Indian equities in the 24 months to September 2026, or about $64 billion including October outflows. The selloff was the longest and deepest in the brokerage’s 20-year dataset.
JM Financial tested GDP growth, interest rate differentials, earnings growth, valuations, the rupee, oil prices and capital gains taxation against monthly FII flows.
Its conclusion was that GDP growth has almost no relationship with FII flows, while carry and earnings growth show only small positive links. Valuation tends to influence flows with a lag of four to five months.
Oil, meanwhile, appears to act as a threshold. Since 2016, when Brent averaged above $105 a barrel, FIIs sold in six of seven months, with average monthly outflows of $4.1 billion. When Brent was below $75, average monthly flows were positive.
The brokerage estimates that removing LTCG would add about 2.2 percentage points to an average year’s dollar return for foreign investors. But a return of the market’s P/E multiple to its 10-year average could contribute about 24 percentage points.
That suggests a tax cut may improve the investment proposition, but it is unlikely to override valuations, oil prices, currency movements and global risk appetite.
Sitharaman’s balancing act
The government is therefore confronting two competing arguments. Economists want the current tax structure retained to preserve fiscal discipline and avoid creating a fresh preference for equities over other assets. Investors argue that India is at a competitive disadvantage relative to emerging markets where foreign investors pay no capital gains tax on equities.A tax cut could strengthen sentiment, draw some foreign capital back into largecaps and provide support to the rupee. But the evidence also suggests that FPI flows respond more forcefully to oil prices, valuation and global conditions than to tax changes alone.
With the government already reviewing capital market levies, the decision could become one of the defining market signals in Budget 2027.
(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times.)
Download ET Markets APP