Sebi's MTF crackdown: Jefferies sees limited earnings risk for brokers, exchanges and depositories
SEBI is reportedly considering 5-10% free-float-based caps on margin trading exposure in individual stocks. Jefferies expects limited earnings impact on brokers, exchanges and depositories, estimating a potential 4% worst-case earnings hit for Groww.

SEBI's proposed MTF restrictions could curb excessive leverage in individual stocks, while Jefferies expects limited financial impact on Groww and other market intermediaries.
India's MTF book has grown to around Rs 1.5 lakh crore, nearly doubling over the past two years. Jefferies attributed the growth to regulatory tightening in the index options market and discount broking platforms expanding their margin lending offerings.
However, the brokerage believes the overall exposure of the MTF book to stocks crossing the proposed thresholds remains relatively limited.
"Only 4% of the MTF book comes from stocks with MTF exposure exceeding 10% of free float. However, if we reduce this limit to 5% of free float, the exposure to the MTF book would be 23%," Jefferies said.
The brokerage also noted that India's MTF book is around 1.2 times its cash average daily traded turnover (ADTO), a level similar to China but lower than in developed markets.
ALSO READ: Nvidia shares crash 24% in November so far amid Huang's scandal. Why UBS is slamming 'draconian' assumptions, sees 54% upside
10% free-float cap unlikely to pose significant risk
Jefferies believes a free-float-based MTF cap is a better way to manage the risks of excessive leverage than a broker-level restriction.
"Overall, the MTF book, as a proportion of the free float market cap in India, is low (0.7%). However, MTF exposure is significantly higher in a small group of stocks, drawing SEBI's attention," the brokerage said.
The brokerage estimates that stocks where MTF exposure exceeds 10% of free float account for just 2% of stocks on which MTF is permitted and 4% of the overall MTF book.
At a lower threshold of 5%, these stocks account for 11% of eligible stocks and 23% of the MTF book.
Brokers most exposed, but earnings impact could remain limited
Bank-backed brokers currently have greater exposure to MTF compared with discount brokers, making the potential impact of the proposed restrictions different across brokerage firms.
Groww has the lowest MTF exposure among key discount brokers, with a share of around 3%, according to Jefferies. However, its MTF book has grown sevenfold since FY25 to approximately Rs 43 billion.
The segment accounted for around 9% of Groww's operating revenues in the first half of FY27. Despite this growth, MTF penetration remains relatively low, with just 1.1% of its active cash broking customers using the facility in the second quarter of FY27.
For peers, MTF penetration among active stock traders is around 2.5-3%, the brokerage estimated.
Jefferies does not believe the proposed free-float-based restrictions pose a significant risk to Groww's earnings growth.
"We do not think free-float-based MTF caps are a risk to Groww's earnings growth," the brokerage said.
It cited lower MTF penetration compared with peers, the possibility of capital shifting towards other products or more-liquid stocks, and the company's steps to reduce exposure to less-liquid and over-leveraged stocks as factors limiting the potential impact.
In a worst-case scenario, assuming Groww loses 23% of its MTF book because of the proposed restrictions, Jefferies estimates an adverse impact of around 4% on its FY28 estimated earnings.
Exchanges and depositories have lower exposure
The proposed restrictions could also affect stock exchanges and depositories through their exposure to MTF-related activities. However, Jefferies expects the impact on these market participants to remain limited.
For depositories, MTF activity drives income from pledged shares. At CDSL, pledge income accounts for around 2-3% of consolidated revenues.
For NSE and BSE, cash-market turnover contributes around 7-11% of revenues, with MTF activity supporting trading volumes in the cash segment.
However, Jefferies expects the impact to be contained as restrictions could lead to a shift in margin funding from less-liquid to more-liquid stocks, potentially limiting the impact on overall trading activity and pledge-related revenues.
"Historical evidence indicates that caps could cause margin funds to shift from less-liquid to more-liquid stocks. Brokers have also curtailed exposure to less-liquid stocks," the brokerage noted.
Impact could remain manageable
Jefferies believes the proposed restrictions are unlikely to pose a material earnings risk to the broader market intermediary segment.
The brokerage expects the impact to remain limited, given the relatively small proportion of the MTF book exposed to stocks crossing the proposed free-float thresholds and the possibility of margin funds shifting towards more-liquid stocks.
"Thus, we see limited risk to Groww, with a c.4% worst-case impact on earnings, and to exchanges and depositories," Jefferies said.
The eventual impact will depend on the final thresholds adopted by SEBI and how the proposed restrictions are implemented.
Disclosure: This article has been written by Kumar Gaurav, who is not a Sebi-registered Research Analyst or an Investment Adviser. Gaurav and their ‘relative(s)’ (as defined under Section 2(77) of the Companies Act, 2013) do not hold any financial interest in the companies mentioned in this article as of the date of publication. The views/recommendations mentioned in this article, wherever applicable, are those of the respective Sebi-registered Research Analyst/brokerage and have been reproduced/reported with due attribution. They should not be construed as the views or recommendations of The Economic Times Digital or the journalist. Readers are advised to consider the original research report and make their investment decisions based on their own assessment. Brokerage disclaimers here
Download ET Markets APP