Not everyone's winning! How Nifty's 14% sprint left 10 heavyweight stocks in the dust
The Nifty index has experienced an impressive increase of over 14% lately, fueled by a surge in foreign investments. Despite this market frenzy, ten prominent stocks, including Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles and Coal India, faltered and failed to ...

An analysis of ACE Equity data shows that 10 Nifty stocks have delivered less than half the benchmark's returns since October 8. These include Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles, Coal India, Nestle India, ONGC, NTPC, Hindalco Industries, Power Grid, Tata Steel, Adani Enterprises and Cipla.
The Nifty climbed 14.2% since the low on October 8, but none of these 10 stocks managed even a 5% return during the period. Three stocks actually declined. Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles was the worst performer, falling 5%, followed by Coal India at 4% and Nestle India at 1.87%.
Why have these stocks missed the rally?
Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles has faced some of the strongest selling pressure following disappointing September-quarter earnings and concerns over the profitability of its British luxury vehicle arm, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR).The automaker reported a consolidated net loss of Rs 5,531 crore for the September quarter, weighed down by exceptional charges of Rs 6,738 crore. JLR has also lowered its FY27 adjusted operating margin guidance to 2-3% from an earlier expectation of around 4%, raising questions about the pace of its recovery.
Also Read: Mahanadi Coalfields IPO: 5 things you should know about Coal India's BCCL and CMPDI listings
The company continues to deal with the effects of last year's cyberattack, higher costs and restructuring expenses.
Motilal Oswal cut its earnings estimates for Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles, reducing its FY27 earnings-per-share forecast by 69% and its FY28 estimate by 5%, citing continued pressure at JLR.
Coal India has also struggled despite reporting a 57% year-on-year increase in September-quarter net profit to Rs 6,547 crore. The state-owned miner's shares came under pressure after its operating earnings missed expectations, prompting brokerages including Jefferies and Motilal Oswal to cut their target prices.
Higher production costs and softer operational performance weighed on sentiment. Coal India's production declined 2.5% during the first half of FY27, even as coal offtake increased 7.6%.
The weakness in Nestle India presents a different picture. The consumer goods company reported a 36% increase in September-quarter profit to Rs 1,027 crore, alongside 20% revenue growth. However, its shares fell sharply after the results, suggesting that investors remained unconvinced about the valuation or sustainability of growth. The stock declined 1.87% over the period under review.
Falling oil prices hurt ONGC
ONGC, which gained just 1.69%, has faced an unusual challenge from one of the same factors supporting the broader market rally: falling crude oil prices. Lower oil prices generally benefit India by reducing its import bill and easing inflationary pressure. However, they can hurt upstream producers such as ONGC because lower realisations affect earnings from crude production.The two major power utilities, NTPC and Power Grid, also lagged the benchmark. NTPC returned 3.91%, while Power Grid gained 5.46%. Their relatively modest gains came as investors favoured banking and other stocks seen as direct beneficiaries of improving earnings and foreign inflows.
NTPC's performance was particularly notable because the company reported a 14% YoY increase in standalone September-quarter profit to Rs 5,320 crore, prompting positive commentary from brokerages. The divergence suggests that even healthy quarterly earnings have been insufficient to guarantee market-beating returns during the recent rally.
Read More: Nifty on course to record its best month since November 2020. Is the big money already made?
Metals struggle to match Nifty
Metal stocks have also delivered mixed performances despite improving earnings. Hindalco Industries gained 4.22%, while Tata Steel advanced 5.55%, both well below the Nifty's rise.
Hindalco reported a 59% increase in September-quarter profit, helped by a one-time gain, while revenue rose 39%. However, concerns about margin pressure at its US subsidiary Novelis weighed on sentiment, with Hindalco shares falling around 5% ahead of its earnings announcement.
Tata Steel, meanwhile, reported a 16% rise in quarterly profit to nearly Rs 3,700 crore, supported by stronger operating performance. The company nevertheless faces concerns around debt and the sustainability of steel margins. Its consolidated net debt stood at Rs 91,423 crore at the end of September.
Adani Enterprises, which returned 5.74%, also reported weaker profitability despite higher revenue. Its September-quarter net profit declined 55% YoY to Rs 1,492 crore, even as revenue jumped 75%.
Why is Nifty racing ahead?
The broader market recovery has been fuelled by an extraordinary reversal in foreign investor flows. Foreign portfolio investors invested Rs 84,290 crore in Indian equities during November 2-13, reversing months of heavy selling.VK Vijayakumar, Chief Investment Strategist at Geojit Investments said the shift in global investment preferences was supporting India's recovery. "This rally, which has more steam left, will be led again by largecaps," Vijayakumar said.
According to Jefferies, the Nifty 100 gained 9% from mid-October through its latest review period, compared with 4% for the Nifty Midcap 150 and 2% for the Nifty Smallcap 250. The brokerage expects the reversal in foreign flows to remain more favourable for large-cap stocks.
Data: Ritesh Presswala
Disclosure: This article has been written by Podishetti Akash, who is not a SEBI-registered Research Analyst or an Investment Adviser. Podishetti Akash and his ‘relative(s)’ (as defined under Section 2(77) of the Companies Act, 2013) do not hold any financial interest in the companies mentioned in this article as of the date of publication. The views/recommendations mentioned in this article, wherever applicable, are those of the respective SEBI-registered Research Analyst/brokerage and have been reproduced/reported with due attribution. They should not be construed as the views or recommendations of The Economic Times Digital or the journalist. Readers are advised to consider the original research report and make their investment decisions based on their own assessment. Brokerage disclosures here.
Download ET Markets APP