India Inc’s earnings grew over 17% since 2019 but why stocks delivered less than 11% return

Since 2019, India's earnings per share have grown at a remarkable rate of approximately 17.5%, far exceeding the stock returns of just 10.7% from the Nifty index during the same time frame. This discrepancy highlights valuation contraction while p...

ETMarkets.com
India’s companies have delivered a powerful earnings recovery since the pandemic, but investors have captured only a fraction of that growth as the market subsequently surrendered part of its valuation premium when price-to-earnings multiples contracted.

India’s earnings per share compounded at about 17.5% since 2019, while the country’s equity index returned only 10.7%, according to DSP Mutual Fund. The gap reflects a 13% decline in the market’s P/E multiple over the period.

In other words, earnings did the heavy lifting but valuation acted as a drag. “Earnings tell you how much the business grows, while valuation tells you how much of that growth the investor gets to keep,” DSP said in its Netra report.


The gap is even clearer when the earnings and market indices are rebased to December 2019. India’s earnings roughly tripled, while the index doubled. DSP’s “conversion ratio”, the extent to which earnings growth translated into market performance, was 0.63 times.

That makes India different from Taiwan, where earnings tripled but the index rose 4.5 times, helped by a significant re-rating linked to artificial-intelligence-related earnings visibility. South Korea’s earnings rose fivefold and the index gained 2.9 times.

India, by contrast, experienced a de-rating even as profits rose.
ADVERTISEMENT

Also Read |Nifty profit growth hits 17-quarter high at 27%, upgrades now outpace downgrades. Is earnings cycle turning?

Earnings did the heavy lifting

The post-pandemic earnings recovery has been exceptional by India’s own historical standards. From January 2020 to August-September 2026, India’s earnings index rose from 100 to roughly 225, implying annualised growth of nearly 13% in local currency, DSP said. That compares with only about 5%-6% annual earnings growth between 2008 and 2019.

Corporate restructuring, lower interest costs, cleaner balance sheets, operating leverage and higher margins helped drive the acceleration. Listed company return on equity rose to around 16% in FY26 from roughly 11%-12% before the pandemic.

India has also achieved this growth without the concentrated technology and semiconductor boom that lifted Taiwan and South Korea.
ADVERTISEMENT

DSP describes India’s advantage as the quality and persistence of its earnings rather than simply the speed of growth. Since 2010, India has delivered a 9.1% EPS compound annual growth rate, with only three down years out of 16.

Its earnings volatility was 28%, compared with 62% for Taiwan, 36% for South Korea and 90% for Brazil. About 28% of Indian companies also delivered average return on equity above 20% over 10 years, second only to the US among the markets studied.
ADVERTISEMENT

That consistency is why India continues to command a premium valuation even after the de-rating.

“India is the only compounder among EMs,” DSP said, pointing to the country’s combination of earnings growth, lower volatility and a relatively deep pool of high-return businesses.

Also Read |Nifty profit growth hits 17-quarter high at 27%, upgrades now outpace downgrades. Is earnings cycle turning?

The premium compressed

India’s market was not cheap when the current earnings cycle began. Investors had already assigned a premium to the country’s structural growth, balance sheet improvement and earnings visibility.

As actual earnings caught up, the valuation premium became harder to sustain. The result was a market in which earnings growth was strong enough to support prices, but not strong enough to overcome the decline in the multiple investors were willing to pay.

DSP estimates India’s long-term EPS growth trend at about 9.1%, almost half the post-Covid growth rate. At current valuations, that trend alone can support roughly 9%-10% annual returns in local currency without requiring a meaningful re-rating.

Its five-year scenario analysis estimates a 9.5% annualised return for India if earnings grow at their 2010-25 trend and the P/E ratio moves back towards its historical median. The valuation component contributes only 0.4 percentage point to that return.

That is a crucial change in the market equation. India no longer needs a major valuation expansion to generate reasonable returns. The burden has shifted back to earnings compounding.

Across five emerging markets, DSP found that stocks bought in the cheapest P/E quintile generated an average subsequent three-year annualised return of 11.5%, compared with only 3.5% for stocks in the richest quintile.

The historical relationship between starting valuation and future returns was strong, with the correlation between P/E and subsequent P/E change ranging from minus 0.69 to minus 0.84 across most markets. For India, the correlation was minus 0.74.

India was an exception in one respect: even the richest P/E quintile generated a 13.9% forward annualised return in the study. DSP attributed the stickiness of the premium partly to buoyant sentiment, mispricing and the quality of Indian earnings.

Not all earnings growth is equal

DSP cautioned against extrapolating the recent earnings performance of Taiwan and South Korea.

South Korea’s post-Covid EPS growth has been about 26% annually, compared with only 3.1% between 2010 and 2025. In 2026, earnings rose 188% on a memory upcycle while the index gained 44%, even as the P/E multiple halved.

Taiwan’s earnings growth has also been boosted by the artificial-intelligence capital-expenditure cycle. Its valuation reached the 96th-98th percentile of its historical range, according to DSP.

Three companies — SK Hynix, TSMC and Samsung Electronics — account for nearly 70% of profit growth in their respective markets. Samsung’s third-quarter operating profit was roughly nine times its year-earlier level, while SK Hynix’s was more than seven times.

Such growth may be real, but it is difficult to repeat indefinitely.

India’s earnings are less concentrated and less cyclical. That supports the country’s premium, but it also means that future returns are likely to look more like the long-term earnings trend than the exceptional post-pandemic performance.

Q2 supports the earnings case

The second quarter earnings season has so far reinforced the underlying case for India. BSE 500 profit growth accelerated to 25.1% year-on-year in the second quarter of fiscal 2027, compared with 10.9% in the first quarter, according to Emkay. Nifty 50 profit growth was 26%, while EBITDA margins recovered about 250 basis points sequentially to 15.9%.

Motilal Oswal Financial Services reported 32% profit growth for its coverage universe. Excluding oil-marketing companies, profit growth was 30%. Large-cap earnings rose 31%, mid-cap earnings 22% and small-cap earnings 32%.

However, the improvement was not evenly distributed. Banking, financial services, metals, oil and gas, and automobiles accounted for 77% of incremental year-on-year earnings growth in the Motilal Oswal universe.

Emkay also flagged a deterioration in operating cash flows. BSE 500 operating cash flow as a share of EBITDA fell to 63.9% in the first half of fiscal 2027 from 82.5% in fiscal 2026. The weakness was concentrated in discretionary, industrial and materials companies.

That makes cash conversion an important test for the next leg of the market. Strong reported profit growth will need to translate into cash generation if valuations are to stabilise.

Promoter selling factor

DSP’s analysis also offers another explanation for why strong earnings have not produced stronger returns: the supply of shares has increased as promoters monetised elevated valuations.

The 12-month total of promoter selling across primary and secondary markets was close to $43 billion by October, near the highest level in the report’s series. The current run-rate was about 3.5 times the 2015 peak and more than 1.5 times the 2021 peak.

In 2025, promoters sold about ₹1.38 lakh crore through secondary-market transactions, while promoter buying was only around ₹2,300 crore which is roughly ₹60 of selling for every ₹1 of buying.

DSP’s historical analysis found that the median stock had already risen 39% in the 12 months before a promoter sale. Almost 64% of promoter sales occurred in the top 40% of a company’s own historical valuation range, while 44% occurred in the most expensive valuation quintile.

For the next phase, the return equation is likely to depend on three factors: whether earnings remain broad-based, whether profit growth converts into cash flow, and whether the market’s premium can stabilise rather than expand.

India’s stocks returned only 10.7% despite 17.5% earnings growth because the market had to absorb a valuation contraction. With the P/E ratio now closer to its historical median, DSP’s analysis suggests that the hurdle for future returns is lower.

(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)
ADVERTISEMENT
READ MORE

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Markets › Stocks › News › India Inc’s earnings grew over 17% since 2019 but why stocks delivered less than 11% return
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+