Mahanadi Coalfields IPO: Subscribe or buy Coal India, BCCL, CMPDI shares instead? Where is the value for investors?
Mahanadi Coalfields Limited is generating buzz with its recent initial public offering, priced between Rs 129-136 per share. This has resulted in mixed feedback from investors. While some analysts recommend subscribing to MCL for direct exposure, ...

The public offering of Mahanadi Coalfields comprises 66.18 crore equity shares and is entirely an offer for sale (OFS) by existing shareholders, meaning the company will not receive any proceeds from the issue. The IPO is priced in the band of Rs 129-136 per share, with a lot size of 110 shares and a minimum retail investment of Rs 14,960 at the upper end.
The issue, which opened on November 19 and closes on November 23, was subscribed 38% on the first day. While qualified institutional buyers (QIBs) subscribed 1.26 times their allotted portion, retail investor participation stood at 13% of the shares reserved for the category.
Brokerage firm Anand Rathi has assigned a 'Subscribe – Long Term' rating to the IPO, citing MCL's market leadership, sizeable coal reserves, low-cost mechanised operations, strong profitability and established evacuation infrastructure. The brokerage has also factored in the structural and regulatory challenges associated with coal mining.
Sensex, Nifty today; Catch all the LIVE stock market action here
MCL's operating edge comes at a premium
While MCL's operating performance is a key attraction, its valuation relative to Coal India has emerged as an important consideration for investors.Avinash Gorakshakar, founder of Avinash Mentor Research, believes MCL offers superior operational quality and margin efficiency, while Coal India provides a more attractive overall risk-reward proposition, valuation cushion and diversification.
"At current market levels Mahanadi Coalfields Limited, whose Rs 8,981 crore IPO opened today, offers the best pure-play operational quality and margin efficiency, while parent Coal India Limited offers the most attractive overall risk reward, valuation cushion, and diversification," Gorakshakar said.
He describes MCL as the crown jewel of Coal India, pointing to its contribution to the parent's production and profitability.
"MCL is the crown jewel of Coal India, generating 28% of CIL's coal output (218.3 MT) and roughly one third of CIL's consolidated PAT (Rs 10,698 crore in FY26)," he said.
According to Gorakshakar, MCL's mining profile gives it a significant cost advantage over some of Coal India's other subsidiaries.
Also Read: Anthropic's $2 trillion debut fails to revive appetite for AI stocks; Asia heads for worst week in 6 years. What's happening?
"Because 99.85% of its production is opencast using surface miners, MCL enjoys the lowest cost per tonne in the group and a strong 47.45% EBITDA margin which is far superior to legacy underground heavy subsidiaries like ECL and BCCL," he said.
However, the valuation comparison favours the parent. At Rs 136, MCL is priced at 8.4 times FY26 earnings, compared with 7.2 times for Coal India, according to Gorakshakar.
He also flags the geographical and customer concentration risks associated with MCL's operations. The company operates entirely in Odisha, with 55.9% of revenue linked to its top 10 customers. It also has Rs 2,432 crore in overdue receivables concentrated among power utilities in Andhra Pradesh.
"Coal India diversifies geographic, logistics and state utility default risks across eight states," Gorakshakar said.
Explaining his preference for Coal India, he said, "Hence it is better to have an exposure to CIL where valuations are cheaper and where the entire business of MCL gets accounted in the consolidated numbers of CIL."
However, Gorakshakar sees a case for investors seeking direct exposure to MCL's operating performance.
"If one wants a direct exposure to India's lowest-cost, highest-margin coal asset without subsidising weaker loss-making subsidiaries (like ECL/BCCL), MCL is far superior to BCCL and worth accumulating at or below the Rs 136 IPO price for long-term," he said.
Coal India offers better risk-reward
Vinit Bolinjkar, Head of Research at Ventura, also highlights MCL's strong operating profile but believes Coal India currently offers a more attractive proposition on valuation and diversification."Mahanadi Coalfields is a high-quality, cash-generative coal business, but at the upper IPO band of Rs 136 it is valued at about 8.4 times FY26 earnings, compared with roughly 7.7 times for Coal India on a comparable FY26 basis," Bolinjkar said.
MCL produced 218.3 million tonnes of coal in FY26 and contributed approximately 34% of Coal India's FY26 profit. Its earnings momentum has also remained positive, with revenue increasing around 9% and profit growing approximately 7% year on year in the first half of FY27.
"For a risk-adjusted investor, Coal India currently looks more attractive on valuation and diversification: it retains about 90% of MCL and also owns the group's other operating subsidiaries," Bolinjkar said.
Direct investment in MCL, according to Bolinjkar, may appeal to investors looking for focused exposure to the subsidiary's operating performance. However, he believes the IPO valuation does not offer a material discount to the parent.
Comparing MCL with Coal India's other listed subsidiaries, he noted that CMPDI trades at a higher earnings multiple, while BCCL's recent profit recovery needs to be assessed against its volatile earnings base.
"Our preference would therefore be Coal India for broader exposure and valuation; MCL for investors specifically seeking the subsidiary's focused coal exposure," Bolinjkar said.
Disclosure: This article has been written by Kumar Gaurav, who is not a Sebi-registered Research Analyst or an Investment Adviser. Gaurav and their ‘relative(s)’ (as defined under Section 2(77) of the Companies Act, 2013) do not hold any financial interest in the companies mentioned in this article as of the date of publication. The views/recommendations mentioned in this article, wherever applicable, are those of the respective Sebi-registered Research Analyst/brokerage and have been reproduced/reported with due attribution. They should not be construed as the views or recommendations of The Economic Times Digital or the journalist. Readers are advised to consider the original research report and make their investment decisions based on their own assessment. Brokerage disclaimers here
Download ET Markets APP