Writer Sarah Aboobacker wins plagiarism case against makers of 2011 National Award-winning film 'Byari'

The writer had claimed that the movie makers had used her story without permission.

BCCL
The court directed the film makers to pay a compensation of Rs 2 lakh to Sarah Aboobacker.
MANGALURU: Noted Kannada writer Sarah Aboobacker has won a legal battle against the makers of the 2011 national award-winning film 'Byari,' which she claimed was based on her much-acclaimed novel 'Chandragiriya Teeradalli.'

'Byari,' the first film in Beary language, directed by K P Suveeran and produced by Altaf Hussain, had won the Swarna Kamal for best film at the 59th national film awards.

Hussain also plays a character in a prominent role in the film.


She had moved the court against the film's producer and director saying the movie makers had used her story without permission.

Judging A Book By Its Cover: Authors Who Stirred A Storm
1/6

The Bombay High Court has restrained industrialist Vijaypat Singhania from releasing his tell-all memoir. Here are other tomes that took a page out of controversy’s book.

The Bombay High Court has restrained industrialist Vijaypat Singhania from releasing his tell-all memoir. Here are other tomes that took a page out of controversy’s book.
In June 2012, American rapper Jay-Z (in pic) was sued by writer Patrick White. The latter claimed that large parts of the musician’s 2010 autobiography, Decoded, was a product of plagiarism. White claimed that his laptop was stolen in 2009, a year before the book was published, and that the book contained “expressions/colours/ phrases” that co-related to his work. In fact, the book was a collection of Jay-Z’s songs and the story behind how each one was made.


(Image: AFP)
In June 2012, American rapper Jay-Z (in pic) was sued by writer Patrick White. The latter claimed that large parts of the musician’s 2010 autobiography, Decoded, was a product of plagiarism. White cl..
Read More
After Lance Armstrong (in pic) confessed to using performance-enhancing drugs, two of his fans sued him in January 2013 for lying in his two memoirs — It’s Not About the Bike (2000) and Every Second Counts (2003). Rob Stutzman and Jonathan Wheeler said they wouldn’t have bought the books if they knew they were works of fiction.
After Lance Armstrong (in pic) confessed to using performance-enhancing drugs, two of his fans sued him in January 2013 for lying in his two memoirs — It’s Not About the Bike (2000) and Every Second..
Read More
American author Augusten Burroughs (in pic) was sued by his foster family, the Turcottes, for defaming them in his 2002 memoir Running with Scissors. In his book, Burroughs describes his life after his chainsmoking mother asked her psychiatrist Dr Rodolph Turcotte to be his legal guardian so that he could attend school in Northampton, Massachusetts. The Turcottes filed a suit against him in 2005 claiming large parts of the book were untrue. These included the family condoning affairs between adults and children and keeping an electroshock machine hidden under the stairs. Burroughs settled the suit in 2007. The book was then classified as fiction instead of a memoir.
American author Augusten Burroughs (in pic) was sued by his foster family, the Turcottes, for defaming them in his 2002 memoir Running with Scissors. In his book, Burroughs describes his life after h..
Read More
Celebrated English concert pianist James Rhodes (in pic) had to fight his ex-wife in court to publish his 2015 autobiography, Instrumental: A Memoir of Madness, Medication and Music. She filed an injunction in court in October 2014 that sought to stop publication on the grounds that it would psychologically harm their 12-year-old son who had been detected with Asperger’s Syndrome. The book gave details of sexual abuse that the pianist had faced as a child. In May 2015, the court overturned the injunction, clearing the path for the publication of the book.
Celebrated English concert pianist James Rhodes (in pic) had to fight his ex-wife in court to publish his 2015 autobiography, Instrumental: A Memoir of Madness, Medication and Music. She filed an inj..
Read More
Mineko Iwasaki, the inspiration for Memoirs of a Geisha, filed a lawsuit against author Arthur Golden (in pic) in 2001. She claimed that despite being promised that her name would be kept confidential, Golden mentioned her in the novel’s acknowledgments. While Golden had told Iwasaki that he was only researching for his book when he interviewed her, the lives of many of the characters in the book closely mirrored hers. The lawsuit was settled out of court in 2003.
Mineko Iwasaki, the inspiration for Memoirs of a Geisha, filed a lawsuit against author Arthur Golden (in pic) in 2001. She claimed that despite being promised that her name would be kept confidenti..
Read More

Upholding her contention, the third additional district and sessions court here in its judgement directed Altaf Hussain, the producer, not to screen the movie anywhere henceforth.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Judge B Muralidhar Pai noted that there was an infringement of her intellectual property rights.

It also directed the film makers to pay a compensation of Rs 2 lakh with interest for the period of trial in the case (eight years and 12 days) along with court costs.

The writer, in a press note here said her novel was published as a serial in 'Lankesh Patrike' and had been widely read with passion and much debated.

The brazen act of the film-makers in using her novel for the film without taking permission forced her to approach the court for justice, she said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Magazines › Panache › Writer Sarah Aboobacker wins plagiarism case against makers of 2011 National Award-winning film 'Byari'
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+