Weinstein rape trial: Defence expert says some memories can become 'contaminated' over time
A psychologist said that an event sometimes causes a 'misinformation effect', where false details become memory.
By PTI | Updated:
Reuters
NEW YORK: A psychologist called by Harvey Weinstein's defence team said memories of an incident can become "contaminated" over time by new information, as testimony in his rape trial entered its closing stages on Friday.
Elizabeth Loftus, a University of California, Irvine professor, said leading questioning about an event sometimes causes a "misinformation effect," where false details are incorporated into someone's memory.
"If you are urged to remember more, in trying to produce more to satisfy that situation, you may produce something like a guess and then it starts to feel like a memory," she testified.
Since testimony began on January 22, six women have taken the stand to say they were sexually assaulted by Weinstein.
All of the allegations against the former Hollywood titan are at least six years old, while one of them dates back three decades.
Weinstein, 67, faces life imprisonment if convicted of predatory sexual assault charges related to ex-actress Jessica Mann and former production assistant Mimi Haleyi.
Mann says Weinstein raped her in March 2013 while Haleyi alleges he forcibly performed oral sex on her in 2006.
The defense says the women willingly had sex to advance their own careers and that Weinstein was in relationships with them.
Mann admitted to the court that she had had "non-coerced" sexual contact with Weinstein, producer of "Pulp Fiction" and "Sin City," up to 2016.
Sexual assault allegations against Weinstein made headlines worldwide in October 2017, igniting the #MeToo movement.
It all started with Harvey Weinstein in 2017 and four months in to 2018 and now with Bill Cosby's conviction, things are certainly looking up for the #MeToo movement. The number of cases of sexual harassment in Hollywood that have come to light since 2017 has been outstanding. It could also be called the 'Weinstein Effect'. Many of the women who spoke out against Weinstein -- Gwyneth Paltrow, Ashley Judd, Rose McGowan -- are famous names.
2018 has been no different and in a breakthrough trial, after decades of whispers, lawsuits, investigations and close calls - and a multitude of women who lost hope anyone would ever believe their word against that of America's Dad - Bill Cosby could be headed to prison at age 80 for the remainder of his life. Cosby's conviction will only bolster the #MeToo movement.
But they weren't alone, it was almost like a Pandora's Box was opened and a lot of names came out. Let's look at all the accused men:
Loftus - who testified in about 300 trials, mostly for the defense - said media coverage can lead people to change their recollection of an incident.
"It does not mean the person is lying but their memory could have been transformed," Loftus added.
The psychologist said memory can also be distorted from the start by alcohol or drugs, particularly Valium, a sedative.
"The Sopranos" actress Annabella Sciorra testified that she was taking Valium around the time she says Weinstein raped her in the early 1990s.
Under cross-examination Loftus said that for traumatic events it is mostly "peripheral memories" that become distorted, "not the core of the event." The prosecution rested its case on Thursday and closing arguments are expected next week, well ahead of schedule.
The trial has raised complicated issues surrounding consent for the jury of 12 to grapple with.
"It was much more clear-cut in the Bill Cosby case. He drugged the victim," said Pace University law professor Bennett Gershman, referring to the US comedian convicted of sexual assault in 2018.
The jury must reach a unanimous verdict. If it can't then the judge may be forced to declare a mistrial.
"It takes just one juror to say, 'I don't buy it,'" said criminal defense lawyer Julie Rendalman. "I think it's going to be difficult to reach a verdict," she added.
Elizabeth Loftus, a University of California, Irvine professor, said leading questioning about an event sometimes causes a "misinformation effect," where false details are incorporated into someone's memory.
"If you are urged to remember more, in trying to produce more to satisfy that situation, you may produce something like a guess and then it starts to feel like a memory," she testified.
Since testimony began on January 22, six women have taken the stand to say they were sexually assaulted by Weinstein.
All of the allegations against the former Hollywood titan are at least six years old, while one of them dates back three decades.
Weinstein, 67, faces life imprisonment if convicted of predatory sexual assault charges related to ex-actress Jessica Mann and former production assistant Mimi Haleyi.
ADVERTISEMENT
Mann says Weinstein raped her in March 2013 while Haleyi alleges he forcibly performed oral sex on her in 2006.
The defense says the women willingly had sex to advance their own careers and that Weinstein was in relationships with them.
Mann admitted to the court that she had had "non-coerced" sexual contact with Weinstein, producer of "Pulp Fiction" and "Sin City," up to 2016.
Sexual assault allegations against Weinstein made headlines worldwide in October 2017, igniting the #MeToo movement.
ADVERTISEMENT
2018 has been no different and in a breakthrough trial, after decades of whispers, lawsuits, investigations and close calls - and a multitude of women who lost hope anyone would ever believe their word against that of America's Dad - Bill Cosby could be headed to prison at age 80 for the remainder of his life. Cosby's conviction will only bolster the #MeToo movement.
But they weren't alone, it was almost like a Pandora's Box was opened and a lot of names came out. Let's look at all the accused men:
Loftus - who testified in about 300 trials, mostly for the defense - said media coverage can lead people to change their recollection of an incident.
ADVERTISEMENT
"If it is relabeled, it can be remembered as more upsetting and traumatic than it was at the time," she said. "It does not mean the person is lying but their memory could have been transformed," Loftus added.
The psychologist said memory can also be distorted from the start by alcohol or drugs, particularly Valium, a sedative.
"The Sopranos" actress Annabella Sciorra testified that she was taking Valium around the time she says Weinstein raped her in the early 1990s.
Under cross-examination Loftus said that for traumatic events it is mostly "peripheral memories" that become distorted, "not the core of the event." The prosecution rested its case on Thursday and closing arguments are expected next week, well ahead of schedule.
The trial has raised complicated issues surrounding consent for the jury of 12 to grapple with.
"It was much more clear-cut in the Bill Cosby case. He drugged the victim," said Pace University law professor Bennett Gershman, referring to the US comedian convicted of sexual assault in 2018.
The jury must reach a unanimous verdict. If it can't then the judge may be forced to declare a mistrial.
"It takes just one juror to say, 'I don't buy it,'" said criminal defense lawyer Julie Rendalman. "I think it's going to be difficult to reach a verdict," she added.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
ADVERTISEMENT
