Explainer: How will R. Kelly's 30-year prison sentence impact his other trials?

Pleading guilty to the remaining charges would mean no more trials.

AP
If the 55-year-old loses at three related trials in coming months, he could be staring at decades more behind bars.
R. Kelly could be in his 80s before the singer is free again, based on a 30-year prison term imposed this week by a New York federal judge for parlaying his fame to sexually abuse young fans, including some who were children.

And if the 55-year-old loses at three related trials in coming months, he could be staring at decades more behind bars. That prospect, said one of his lawyers not involved in the New York trial, could lead Kelly to pursue a plea deal.

Here's a look at the potential impact of Kelly's lengthy prison term in New York on those other cases:


What Is The Status Of The Cases?
A federal trial in Chicago is slated to begin next, on Aug. 15. Chicago is Kelly's hometown and where many of his accusers live, so interest is expected to be especially intense. Kelly faces charges that he and two co-defendants fixed his state child pornography trial in 2008, when he was acquitted.

The two other cases are state cases: a multiple count sex-abuse case in Cook County, Illinois, where Chicago is located, and a solicitation case in Hennepin County, Minnesota. Both have been on back burners while the federal cases play out. No trial dates are set for either.

What Are The Chances Kelly Pursues A Plea Deal?
ADVERTISEMENT
The chances are greater after the sentence handed down in New York, said Steve Greenberg, a longtime Kelly lawyer who represents Kelly in the Cook County case.

"I suspect there have been discussions" between Kelly's federal trial-team lawyers and prosecutors, Greenberg said.

A message seeking comment from Kelly's lead attorney in his federal cases, Jennifer Bonjean, was not immediately returned. She said earlier that Kelly would appeal his New York convictions.

Kelly must weigh the likelihood of winning the Chicago federal case against agreeing to a deal that includes more prison time, Greenberg said.

ADVERTISEMENT
But Greenberg believes the cases against Kelly in Cook County and in Minnesota are far weaker and that Kelly could secure acquittals in those state courts.

Would Another Sentence Be Added To The New York Sentence?
If Kelly is convicted in U.S. District Court in Chicago, his judge could order that Kelly serve that sentence after his New York sentence is complete, said Phil Turner, a former federal prosecutor in Chicago with no tie to Kelly's cases.
ADVERTISEMENT

Turner said he expected prosecutors would ask for such a consecutive sentence but that a judge would most likely impose a concurrent sentence - meaning they would be served simultaneously.
R Kelly Gets 30 Yrs In Prison In Sex Case: History Of Accusations Against The Singer
1/10

American songwriter-record producer R Kelly, Robert Sylvester Kelly, was sentenced to 30 years in prison on June 30 for leading a decade-long effort to recruit and trap teenagers and women for sex.

American songwriter-record producer R Kelly, Robert Sylvester Kelly, was sentenced to 30 years in prison on June 30 for leading a decade-long effort to recruit and trap teenagers and women for sex.

American songwriter-record producer R Kelly, Robert Sylvester Kelly, was sentenced to 30 years in prison on June 30 for leading a decade-klong effort to recruit and trap teenagers and women for sex. The sentence, stiffer than the 25 years in prison that prosecutors had sought, caps a long downfall for the 55-year-old former superstar. The singer has been in jail since July 2019. In September 2021, Kelly was found guilty of eight counts of sex trafficking and one of racketeering in a New York court.

For over two decades, Kelly faced several allegations of sexual abuse, accounts going back to the start of his career in the 1990s.

American songwriter-record producer R Kelly, Robert Sylvester Kelly, was sentenced to 30 years in prison on June 30 for leading a decade-klong effort to recruit and trap teenagers and women for sex. ..
Read More

When Kelly was 27, he married Aaliyah at a secret ceremony in Chicago. The singer had lied about her age and listed herself as 18, but she was just 15 years old at that time. Vibe magazine later discovered Aaliyah's real age. The marriage was then annulled in February 1995. A former tour manager for Kelly later testified at his trial that he had bribed a government worker in 1994 to obtain a fake ID for Aaliyah so they could get married. In 2001, Aaliyah died in a plane crash.

When Kelly was 27, he married Aaliyah at a secret ceremony in Chicago. The singer had lied about her age and listed herself as 18, but she was just 15 years old at that time. Vibe magazine later disc..
Read More

In 1996, Tiffany Hawkins, the first girl to publicly accuse Kelly of sexual abuse, sued the singer for 10 million for the "personal injuries and emotional distress" she suffered during their three-year relationship.

In court filings, Hawkins said she started having sex with the singer in 1991 when she was 15. Rolling Stone reported that Hawkins had said that she "suffered personal injuries and severe emotional harm because she had sex with him and he encourage her to participate in group sex with him and other underage girls." The case was settled in 1998 for $250,000.

In 1996, Tiffany Hawkins, the first girl to publicly accuse Kelly of sexual abuse, sued the singer for 10 million for the "personal injuries and emotional distress" she suffered during their three-ye..
Read More

Kelly is charged with 21 counts of making child sexual abuse videos. Chicago police accused him of recording the acts and enticing a minor to participate in them. A video was anonymously sent to the Chicago Sun Times, who passed it on to police and that led to Kelly's arrest.

The singer, who was out on $750,000 bail immediately, denied the charges and later pleaded not guilty in court. It took six years for the case to come to trial where the jury eventually found Kelly not guilty on all counts as they could not prove if the girl on the tape was a minor.

Kelly is charged with 21 counts of making child sexual abuse videos. Chicago police accused him of recording the acts and enticing a minor to participate in them. A video was anonymously sent to the ..
Read More

Buzzfeed report in 2017 accused Kelly of trapping six women in a sex "cult". The article alleged that the singer seduced young girls who had come to him for help with their music careers. The singer was accused by three former employees and the parents of several women.

Buzzfeed report in 2017 accused Kelly of trapping six women in a sex "cult". The article alleged that the singer seduced young girls who had come to him for help with their music careers. The singer ..
Read More

The detailed report by Buzzfeed opened a floodgate of allegations against the singer. Several women came forward and claimed that the singer coerced them into sexual encounters when they were underage, starved them and physically abused them. The #MuteRKelly campaign forced the music label RCA to sever ties with the singer. Meanwhile the singer sang "Only God can mute me" on a song called 'I Admit'.

However, around the same time Kelly was sued by a former partner who claimed he "intentionally gave her sexually transmitted disease".

The detailed report by Buzzfeed opened a floodgate of allegations against the singer. Several women came forward and claimed that the singer coerced them into sexual encounters when they were underag..
Read More

Kelly was accused of two separate federal indictments in 2019. The allegations said that the singer and his associates recruited and transported underage girls over state lines for illegal sexual motives including production of child sex abuse pictures. According to reports, there were around 13 charges against Kelly, who was arrested by NYPD and Homeland Security officials.

Kelly was accused of two separate federal indictments in 2019. The allegations said that the singer and his associates recruited and transported underage girls over state lines for illegal sexual mot..
Read More

In 2019, Minnesota authorities charged Kelly with two counts of prostitution and solicitation involving a case where he was accused of soliciting a teenager who asked him for an autograph in 2001. As per the allegations, Kelly invited the 17-year-old to his hotel room and offered her $200 to undress and dance with him.

In 2019, Minnesota authorities charged Kelly with two counts of prostitution and solicitation involving a case where he was accused of soliciting a teenager who asked him for an autograph in 2001. As..
Read More

Kelly was found guilty of all nine counts against him in September 2021, after a six-week trial revealed how he had used employees and intermediaries to lure fans and hopeful singers into sexually abusive and controlling conditions, including locking them in rooms without food or access to a bathroom for days. Federal prosecutors had asked for a sentence "in excess of 25 years", reflecting Kelly's continued danger to the public and apparent lack of remorse for using his fame to sexually and emotionally abuse alleged victims, many of them underaged.

Kelly was found guilty of all nine counts against him in September 2021, after a six-week trial revealed how he had used employees and intermediaries to lure fans and hopeful singers into sexually ab..
Read More
Would Prosecutors Be Open To A Plea Deal?
They could be, if Kelly agrees to take responsibility for the crimes charged.

Kelly's attorneys likely would not agree to anything that involves the possibility of extending the 30-year sentence and would only sign a deal that foresees sentences lower than 30 years. They would also want assurances prosecutors won't press for consecutive sentences.

Turner said the advantage to Kelly of a deal ending the prospect of more trials is that his attorneys would be able to turn their full attention to the New York appeal.

Greenberg said there was reason to think Kelly could prevail with that appeal. Turner said it was a long shot. But if that sentence is thrown out, Turner said Kelly would be looking at completing what his lawyers would hope are lower sentences in the other districts.

Could Prosecutors Decide To Simply Drop The Others Cases?
Chances of that seem slim.

Turner said the typical mindset in U.S. attorney's offices is to remain persistent and aggressive. That attitude has been particularly pronounced when it comes to Kelly.

"They want this guy badly," Turner said.

U.S. attorney's offices also effectively have unlimited resources, so the costs and time needed for a trial won't dissuade them, he added.

Turner thought it was more likely that the state cases could be dropped, especially if Kelly is convicted in federal court in Chicago and receives additional prison time.

"Their resources are much more limited. They would be spending money they don't have," he said. "They have murders and serious crimes to prosecute. They may ask, 'Why spend (money and time) on Kelly when he is already facing decades behind bars.'"

What Else Could Drive Decisions To Push Ahead With Other Trials?
The possibility that the New York convictions could be overturned is one factor. Kelly could go free immediately if state prosecutors and federal prosecutors in Chicago chose to drop their cases and the New York convictions were overturned.

Prosecutors in the different districts may all see winning convictions and sentences as insurance that Kelly would stay behind bars - even if an appeals court ends up tossing some convictions.

Is There Any Reason For Kelly To Plead Guilty With No Deal?
Pleading guilty to the remaining charges would mean no more trials. It would lower Kelly's legal bills, which at times he has struggled to pay.

But Kelly would have no assurance that prosecutors wouldn't seek the toughest possible sentences.

Still, he could hold out hope that, by pleading guilty and accepting responsibility, judges would be more inclined to hand him sentences on the lower end of the guidelines.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Magazines › Panache › Explainer: How will R. Kelly's 30-year prison sentence impact his other trials?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+