The ₹50 lakh placement trap: Why high-paying jobs may be discouraging young entrepreneurs
The allure of high-paying positions leads many fresh graduates to choose stable jobs rather than pursue entrepreneurial aspirations. While there is a keen interest among students to launch startups, only a few manage to achieve meaningful income. ...
India's higher education system has traditionally focused on preparing graduates for employment. While this remains an important responsibility, the emphasis on placements may also be influencing how young people assess the risks and rewards of entrepreneurship.
A high-paying job offers a predictable income, financial security and a relatively clear career path. Starting a business, by comparison, involves uncertain earnings, the possibility of failure and years of effort before a venture becomes financially sustainable. For a young graduate facing education loans, family expectations and rising living costs, the choice can be difficult.
Why a high salary can change career decisions
The attraction of a large salary package goes beyond the amount credited to a bank account. It offers immediate financial independence and social recognition. It can also help young professionals meet financial commitments much earlier in their careers.
Entrepreneurship requires a different calculation. A founder may spend years developing a product, finding customers and arranging funds without drawing a regular salary. Even a promising idea may struggle to generate revenue.
Dinesh Gulati, COO, IndiaMART, argues that India's education system places greater value on the salaries graduates secure than on the businesses they could establish. "We celebrate the salaries our students command and never ask about the ventures and jobs they could create," Gulati writes.
The distinction matters because a graduate who chooses a corporate job is counted as a placement success. A student who decides to build a company may not deliver an immediate outcome that fits the same institutional measurements.
Student interest does not always translate into businesses
The interest in entrepreneurship among Indian students is not insignificant. The GUESSS India 2023 survey, cited by Gulati, found that 32.5% of college students were nascent entrepreneurs, actively working towards starting a business. However, the article also points to a much smaller proportion of student ventures reaching the revenue stage. This suggests that having an idea or the intention to become a founder is not enough.
Students need access to mentors, early-stage funding, industry networks and opportunities to test their ideas in real markets. Universities that concentrate primarily on placements may not provide the same level of support to students pursuing business ventures.
The difference can also be seen in how academic performance is assessed. Conventional education rewards students for finding correct answers, while entrepreneurship often involves testing uncertain ideas, making mistakes and changing direction.
A failed business attempt may therefore carry an academic and career cost, even when the experience gives a student valuable commercial knowledge.
The financial risk of choosing entrepreneurship
For many young graduates, the decision to start a company is also a household financial decision. A salaried job provides a relatively predictable source of income. It can help with rent, loan repayments and family responsibilities. A startup, particularly in its early years, may offer none of these assurances.
Gulati describes this pressure through the phrase, "The golden handcuffs start at 22, and every EMI thereafter tightens them."
The concern is not that students should reject employment or that every graduate should become an entrepreneur. Rather, the financial and social cost of taking the entrepreneurial route can make it difficult for young people to consider it seriously.
The risk does not necessarily end when a venture closes. A founder returning to the job market may have to explain a period without conventional employment experience. This can discourage students from experimenting with business ideas in the first place.
What universities can change
Gulati said Universities could make entrepreneurship a more practical career option by offering venture projects for academic credits, access to seed funding and structured mentorship from experienced founders.
They could also introduce entrepreneurship leave, allowing students to work on a business without permanently losing their academic or placement opportunities. Alumni networks could help former student founders reconnect with employers if their ventures do not succeed.
Gulati also argues that universities should measure their performance through the businesses their alumni create, the capital they raise and the jobs those ventures generate. Such indicators could complement conventional placement figures.
India does not need to choose between producing employable graduates and encouraging entrepreneurs. Both contribute to economic growth. Companies need skilled employees, while new businesses can create additional employment, develop products and expand markets.
A ₹50 lakh placement is a significant achievement for a graduate. But it should not become the only definition of success for an educational institution. As Gulati puts it, "The answer to not everyone will be a founder cannot be prepare no one to be."
The larger challenge for universities is to ensure that students have the skills and support to choose either path, rather than being pushed towards one by the way success is measured.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.