InGovern questions Zee's Rs 600 crore buyback plan
Zee Entertainment Enterprises has proposed a ₹600 crore share buyback after a recent ₹735.55 crore fundraise. The allocation strategy raises concerns due to limited use of earlier funds for growth objectives. InGovern reported that much of the rai...
In its November Governance Watch report, InGovern said the buyback proposal did not adequately address the apparent contradiction between the company's earlier decision to raise capital for growth and its subsequent move to return ₹600 crore to shareholders.
Zee allotted fully convertible warrants to promoter-group entity Sunbright Mauritius Investments in August and received ₹735.55 crore as upfront consideration. The funds were intended, among other things, to support growth initiatives and strengthen the balance sheet. According to the Monitoring Agency Report by CARE Ratings for the quarter ended September 30, only ₹2.46 crore of the proceeds had been utilised.
While ₹685 crore was held in fixed deposits and about ₹48.09 crore remained in a current account, a portion of the proceeds was transferred to the company's operating account and commingled with regular business funds, it said.
The monitoring agency reported no deviation from the stated objectives of the issue.
Zee's board on November 12 approved a buyback of up to 65.9 million shares at ₹91 apiece, aggregating ₹600 crore. The promoter group indicated that it would not participate in the buyback.
InGovern acknowledged that the proposal was within applicable regulatory thresholds and that the promoters' decision not to participate was a positive procedural feature.
However, it said the limited utilisation of warrant proceeds, commingling of funds, declining Ebitda margins and the unexplained resignation of the company secretary collectively weakened confidence in the quality of capital allocation and governance oversight. The report also flagged pressure on operating profitability. Zee's operating revenue rose 13% year-on-year to ₹2,224.6 crore in the September quarter, while Ebitda declined 52% to ₹70.8 crore. Ebitda margin fell to 3.2% from 7.4%.
InGovern described the proposed buyback as a potential governance concern rather than an unambiguous shareholder-value initiative.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.