InGovern questions Zee's Rs 600 crore buyback, company says warrant funds intact

InGovern raised concerns about Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd's planned Rs 600-crore share buyback and its capital allocation strategy. The advisory firm noted the recent fundraising and questioned the need for returning capital to shareholders...

New Delhi: Proxy advisory firm InGovern has questioned Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd's proposed Rs 600-crore share buyback, flagging potential inconsistencies in the company's capital allocation strategy, weak operating profitability and governance concerns following a recent promoter-linked fundraise.

InGovern, in a report examining the proposed buyback, questioned the rationale for returning a substantial amount of capital to shareholders shortly after ZEEL raised Rs 735.55 crore through a preferential issue of fully convertible warrants to promoter-group entity Sunbright Mauritius Investments Ltd in August.

The advisory firm said the apparent overlap between fundraising for growth and a subsequent capital return warranted greater explanation from the Board, particularly when the company's operating margins were under pressure.


ZEEL, however, said the warrant proceeds remained intact and were earmarked for deployment in line with its long-term strategic priorities.

The company pointed out that the funds were received only towards the end of August 2026 and that the monitoring period under scrutiny ended on September 30, providing a relatively short window for their deployment.

"The principal concern is the apparent inconsistency between the company's recent capital-raising narrative and its current decision to return capital to shareholders," InGovern said.
ADVERTISEMENT

The note stated that it "does not allege any non-compliance or impropriety".

InGovern also acknowledged that the buyback is structured within regulatory thresholds and that the promoter group does not intend to participate, calling these "positive features from a procedural standpoint".

The Board, at its November 12 meeting, approved a buyback of up to 65.93 million equity shares at Rs 91 apiece, aggregating to a maximum of Rs 600 crore. The proposed tender-offer buyback represents 6.86 per cent of the company's existing paid-up equity share capital. The record date has been fixed at November 25, 2026.

The buyback is within the regulatory threshold that permits Board approval without a separate special resolution from shareholders.
ADVERTISEMENT

The promoter and promoter group have indicated that they do not intend to participate in the offer. At least 15 per cent of the proposed buyback, or the number of shares held by small shareholders, whichever is higher, has been reserved for small shareholders.

The company said the buyback reflected the Board's confidence in its intrinsic value and long-term growth prospects, arguing that its current market valuation did not adequately reflect its underlying worth.
ADVERTISEMENT

"The company has consistently taken steps to reward its shareholders and, as acknowledged by the proxy advisory firm, the proposed buyback is a structurally sound initiative designed to further enhance shareholder returns," a company spokesperson said.

The spokesperson cited Chairman R Gopalan's November 12 statement that the Board remained committed to protecting shareholder interests and ensuring prudent and efficient capital allocation. CEO Punit Goenka had also said the buyback reflected the company's growth potential and its ability to capitalise on emerging opportunities.

InGovern's concerns centre partly on the utilisation of the proceeds from the preferential warrant issue. According to the monitoring agency report by CARE Ratings for the quarter ended September 30, ZEEL had utilised only Rs 2.46 crore of the Rs 735.55 crore received as upfront consideration.

Around Rs 685 crore was placed in fixed deposits, while approximately Rs 48.09 crore remained in a current account.

The monitoring agency reported no deviation from the stated objects of the issue. However, it noted that Rs 15.55 crore had been transferred from the warrant subscription account to the company's operating current account, where it was commingled with regular business funds. Subsequent expenditure towards the stated objectives was made from this mixed account, making it difficult to separately identify the precise utilisation of the warrant proceeds.

InGovern said the commingling raised questions about the traceability and monitoring of funds raised through a promoter-linked preferential issue, even though the monitoring agency had not identified any deviation from the stated objectives.

The advisory firm also flagged the gap between the warrant exercise price of Rs 126 and the prevailing market price, warning that the company could receive substantially less than the anticipated funding if the remaining 75 per cent consideration is not received upon exercise of the warrants.

ZEEL said the limited utilisation of the proceeds should be viewed in the context of the short period since the funds were received and reiterated that the capital remained available for deployment towards its strategic priorities.

The disagreement comes against a backdrop of deteriorating operating profitability despite revenue growth. ZEEL's operating revenue rose 13 per cent year-on-year to Rs 2,224.6 crore in the quarter ended September 30, 2026, largely supported by its digital business. However, EBITDA fell 52 per cent to Rs 70.8 crore, with the EBITDA margin declining to 3.2 per cent from 7.4 per cent in the corresponding year-earlier period.

For the first half of FY2027, operating revenue increased 9 per cent to Rs 4,131.9 crore, while EBITDA declined 60 per cent to Rs 149.7 crore. The EBITDA margin contracted to 3.6 per cent from 9.9 per cent a year earlier, and profit after tax fell 46 per cent to Rs 119.9 crore.

The company has attributed the pressure on margins to investments in new initiatives and higher programming, advertising and promotional expenditure, including spending related to FIFA 2026.

Responding to the concerns, ZEEL said the 13 per cent growth in quarterly operating revenue demonstrated its ability to drive sustained profitability over the medium to long term. It maintained that investments across its businesses had strengthened its fundamentals and financial foundation, creating the capital allocation capacity required to support the next phase of growth.

The buyback, InGovern argued, nevertheless raises questions about the relative priority being accorded to shareholder returns over organic investment, balance-sheet strengthening and other business requirements.

The company's cash and treasury investments stood at Rs 2,569.4 crore as of September 30, making the proposed buyback financially feasible, but the advisory firm said the Board should explain why returning capital was preferable to alternative uses of funds at a time of declining profitability.

Governance concerns have also featured in the advisory firm's assessment.

Ashish Agarwal, ZEEL's Chief Compliance Officer and Company Secretary, resigned with effect from October 29, citing personal reasons. The company appointed Sangeeta Shetty to the position from November 2.

InGovern said the resignation, coming amid regulatory scrutiny and other governance developments, warranted greater disclosure to reassure shareholders about continuity in the company's compliance function.

ZEEL said Agarwal's resignation was disclosed in accordance with applicable listing requirements and that continuity had been ensured through Shetty's appointment. It described her as a seasoned professional with more than two decades of experience and said her expertise would help strengthen the company's governance framework, regulatory compliance and shareholder engagement.

The leadership change follows regulatory action by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). In an order dated July 31, 2026, the market regulator restrained ZEEL from accessing the securities market for two months and barred Subhash Chandra and Punit Goenka from dealing in securities for one year in connection with an alleged unauthorised pledge of the company's Hyderabad land.

The Securities Appellate Tribunal subsequently granted interim relief permitting the warrant issue to proceed, subject to the deposit of penalties.

InGovern said the proposed buyback should be assessed against this broader governance backdrop, although it acknowledged that the transaction was within applicable regulatory thresholds and that the promoters had indicated they would not participate.

The advisory firm has called on the Board to provide greater clarity on the strategic rationale for the buyback, the valuation basis for the Rs 91 offer price, the deployment timeline for the balance warrant proceeds and the safeguards governing the segregation and monitoring of funds raised through the preferential issue.

The company said it remained committed to executing its strategic priorities with discipline and transparency while creating sustainable long-term value for shareholders and other stakeholders.

"The company remains confident in the strategic growth path it has pursued with disciplined and structured investments across the business.

"The efforts implemented under the guidance of the Board have enabled the Company to consistently strengthen its business fundamentals and financial foundation, creating the required capital allocation pool to support its next phase of growth," ZEEL said.

"The capital garnered by the company through the preferential issue remains well intact and is earmarked for deployment in line with the company's long-term strategic priorities. The funds were received at the end of August 2026 and the monitoring period being referenced ended on September 30, 2026, providing a relatively short window for deployment."

ZEEL said the 13 per cent growth in operating revenue, as rightly highlighted by the proxy advisory firm, reflects the company's ability to drive sustained profitability over the medium to long term.

"The company has consistently taken steps to reward its shareholders, and as acknowledged by the proxy advisory firm, the proposed buy-back is a structurally sound initiative designed to further enhance shareholder returns," it said.

ZEEL said the company's chairman, R Gopalan, in a press release dated November 12, 2026, has also stated that the Board remains steadfast in its commitment to protect shareholder interests and ensure prudent and efficient capital allocation.

"The approval of the buy-back reflects the Board's belief that the company's intrinsic worth is not adequately reflected in its current market valuation, making the buyback an appropriate avenue to reinforce confidence in the long-term fundamentals of the business," it said, adding that the company's CEO, Punit Goenka, further highlighted that the company remains on a firm growth trajectory and the Board's approval of the buy-back of shares reflects its immense potential and robust capabilities to capitalise on the opportunities ahead.

With respect to the appointment of Sangeeta Shetty as Chief Compliance Officer and Company Secretary, the company disclosed the resignation of its former Chief Compliance Officer and Company Secretary as per the listed disclosure norms and simultaneously ensured continuity by appointing Shetty, a seasoned professional with over two decades of experience, it said.

The company believes her expertise will enable it to further strengthen the governance framework, regulatory compliance and engagement with shareholders, ZEEL said, adding that the company remains firmly committed towards executing its strategic priorities with discipline and transparency while continuing to create sustainable long-term value for shareholders and all its stakeholders.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Industry › Media/Entertainment › InGovern questions Zee's Rs 600 crore buyback, company says warrant funds intact
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+