Brewers say Bhutan Beer escapes both customs and excise duty in Delhi
The Brewers Association of India (BAI), whose members include United Breweries, AB InBev and Carlsberg, has alleged that beer imported from Bhutan enjoys a tax advantage in Delhi because it is exempt from customs duty and attracts lower excise dut...
India applies a 100% customs duty on imported beer but does not charge it on imports from Bhutan. Delhi levies 150% excise duty on the wholesale price of Indian-made beer and 65% on imported beer, a lower rate the BAI says is meant to offset customs duty. Because Bhutan beer pays no customs duty but receives the lower excise rate, the association says it is taxed less than both domestic and other imported beer.
“You can either be an imported beer or a domestic beer. You cannot be both,” BAI Director General Vinod Giri told ET.
The association has proposed applying the same excise duty to Bhutan beer as to Indian beer, and a formula-based ordering system for retail outlets, similar to Kerala's, which bases orders on the previous three months' sales.
The BAI said it had briefed the Group of Ministers formed for Delhi's new excise policy. “There is no concrete action on ground,” Giri said.
According to industry estimates cited by the BAI, Bhutan-made beer holds under 1% of the national market but about 18% in Delhi. The association says the share of national brands in Delhi fell from 91% to 45% after private retail outlets were removed from the city's liquor trade. It alleges that the extra margin on Bhutan beer is used to give retail staff incentives to favour those brands, a practice that, if it occurs, would be unlawful.
The BAI estimates that the government earns an average of Rs 1,045 per case on Indian beer and Rs 822 on Bhutan beer. On an estimated 18 lakh cases, it puts the revenue loss at about Rs 40 crore.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.