UPI’s free era is ending. Who pays, who earns, and who gets left behind?
A slice of UPI is likely to stop being free in the future. At a closed-door roundtable in Bengaluru, the people who build, lend and collect on India’s favourite payments rail debated what this means for merchants, TPAPs and the economics of the ec...
“Why should I bear that cost to get my money back?”
The above two statements appear to stand at two ends of a spectrum. A spectrum that traces the evolution of Unified Payments Interface (UPI) and increasingly looks at the future. One viewpoint framed the imminent question: how will UPI sustain itself, and who will pay for UPI? The other pushed back on the expectations. As India’s digital payments ecosystem increasingly ponders on what happens to the merchants who will pay merchant discount rate (MDR), the third-party application providers (TPAPs) trying to build businesses on UPI, and the payment infrastructure connecting them, the contrarian viewpoints, though articulating different sentiments, set the momentum for a deeper exploration of what the newly proposed MDR means for the next chapter of the ecosystem.
Under a proposed framework, notified by the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI), merchant payments above ₹2,000 on UPI are likely to carry an MDR of 0.4%, capped at ₹300 per transaction, with a flat ₹5 fee in specified categories such as railways and fuel. Everything below ₹2,000 stays free. So does every rupee you send to a friend.
UPI has run on a zero-MDR policy since 2020. For anyone who has happily never had to think about it, MDR is the small fee a merchant pays on a digital transaction. The fee is shared among the banks, payment processors and apps that made it happen. The user has not had to bear any cost. So far, so good. But if that’s how it brought several population segments into the fold of digital payments, it’s also why most participants in the chain have earned little or nothing directly from carrying it.
Sample this: Nearly 96% of UPI transactions, counted by volume, are for less than ₹2,000. But about 65% of the money moving through the system comes from the remaining 4%. Although UPI is usually described as one thing: a public payment rail, open to everyone, used for everything from a ₹20 cup of tea to a large merchant settlement, the usage data, however, reveals an often-overlooked aspect. Inside its seamless public utility infrastructure, UPI functions as two distinct economies. The first is a mass-use economy where UPI has become invisible infrastructure. The second is where larger sums float across retail bills, services, business payments, and higher-value consumer spending. That is where the money is, and where any charge on acceptance will be felt.
The proposed fee does not disturb the first economy. Its impact falls on the second: the higher-value transactions where most of the money is concentrated. Small payments will remain free, but for businesses whose customers routinely transact in thousands of rupees, accepting UPI is set to become a priced service rather than costless infrastructure.
And when payments technology firm Mindgate Solutions, in partnership with PayU, gathered fintech, lending and payments leaders in Bengaluru for a closed-door roundtable titled ‘The Next Wave of UPI: Growth & Innovation’, the thought-leadership forum boldly articulated the zeitgeist: the time has now come to ask who owes what, and to whom, in UPI. As industry leaders shared their honed insights, the room seemed to echo the mood: UPI solved for acceptance; it’s time to solve for intelligence. The conversation invariably turned to more central questions: Who pays to run the rails? Who gets to lend on them? And who guards them when they belong to everyone?
What can merchants gain and how?
The surprise was how little resistance the fee met. A new charge on India’s best-loved free service, and most of those closest to it seemed willing to go along.It can be viewed as the price of continued innovation, where every participant who plays a role in UPI needs to get their share. The decade of zero cost is appearing to be stretched beyond its limits. Banks have seen balances grow. Banks have seen ATM withdrawals go down. Apps have seen large business outcomes come out of it. This makes the present time apt for transition into an MDR-driven era.
So where is the disagreement? It lies in what the merchant receives for that 0.4%.
The objection is not to the fee itself, but to what it buys. For a merchant, a UPI payment is still largely a utility: money moves from the customer’s account to the business’s account, and little else changes. That puts the burden on payment providers to make the merchant proposition tangible: better conversion, reconciliation, settlement visibility, collections, cash-flow intelligence or anything else that turns acceptance into a service rather than a commodity. In essence, if the 0.4% charge simply makes that familiar process more expensive, it will feel like a tax on acceptance rather than an investment in the business. Stakeholders argue that merchants are less likely to accept the proposed fee if UPI continues to be seen as a commodity. For the fee to be justified, payment providers need to offer tangible benefits beyond the transaction itself, such as easier reconciliation, greater settlement visibility, better collections management or cash-flow insights. The fee is more likely to be accepted if payment providers are able to reduce operational friction and help merchants run their businesses more effectively, rather than simply making an existing utility more expensive..
Payment companies are thus increasingly beginning to position themselves as providers of merchant intelligence. A merchant may accept hundreds of digital payments but still struggle to track them, match them with invoices, understand delays, or plan for the cash they will actually have available. If a provider can solve those problems, the fee stops appearing as a charge for moving money and starts becoming a charge for making the business easier to run.
Why has this not existed for years? The answer might lie in how payment gateways spent years competing chiefly on cost, reliability and reach, turning the basic act of processing a transaction into a low-margin commodity. And that left little room to invest in the more demanding work merchants now expect: understanding their data, integrating with their systems, and offering insight that is specific to their business. The industry could not build sophisticated merchant services while the underlying transaction itself earned almost nothing. The fee may change that equation, but only if providers use it to build capabilities merchants can see and value. It must also be considered that the intelligence merchants now want is very difficult for a payment gateway to do on thin margins.
The hidden cost of getting paid
Yet for some, the fee might look less like an investment in the future and more like a cost imposed on recovery.For a shopkeeper, a UPI payment is straightforward: a customer pays for something they want. For a lending business, it is different. The money being collected is the lender’s own; money that a borrower may be in no hurry to return. The idea that a fee would now apply to that act of recovery can be, understandably, difficult for some to accept.
It is also imperative to remember that lending and stockbroking businesses often operate on net margins of 5-7%. Removing 0.3-0.4% from that is not a trivial adjustment; it takes a visible bite out of what remains. In practice, much of the charge may simply be passed along or redistributed within the system rather than absorbed.
The question also divides the fintech sector sharply: would charging for UPI strengthen the largest platforms, or create space for smaller ones?
Some believe that it will favour the big players. Revenue will come from merchant checkouts, and checkouts are precisely where the largest apps already have an advantage. Smaller TPAPs would find themselves under greater pressure. For TPAPs, therefore, MDR is not simply a question of who pays, rather it is a question of whether UPI can finally become an economically viable layer on which smaller players can build.
It was the absence of a revenue model that allowed the largest players to become dominant in the first place. A UPI system with no way to earn money, some are of the opinion, naturally creates monopolies, because only the biggest companies can afford to subsidise payments through other parts of their business. Introducing a revenue stream can therefore finally give smaller challengers a reason to differentiate.
Under the proposed framework, the 0.4% MDR is to be borne by the merchant and paid to its acquiring bank. The customer continues to pay the listed price; the merchant cannot pass the charge on, and UPI apps cannot levy a separate platform fee.
That leaves the merchant with one obvious response: avoid the charge altogether. A customer can be directed from the shop’s merchant QR code to a personal P2P QR code, where the payment is treated as a transfer between two individuals and remains outside the MDR. There can also be a short-term decline in acceptance, along with more mid-sized merchants directing customers towards a personal P2P QR code instead.
Ultimately, the MDR will be judged on two questions: whether merchants can see what the charge pays for, and whether the new revenue model leaves enough room for smaller players to compete.
The growth story nobody is talking about
At the Bengaluru roundtable ‘The Next Wave of UPI: Growth & Innovation’ hosted by payments technology firm Mindgate Solutions, in partnership with PayU, away from the fee debate, the growth story emerged as another bold articulation for the next chapter of UPI.What will drive UPI beyond the QR code? UPI has already solved for scale; the next act demands an even more pervasive, intuitive, and personalised financial relationship. Beyond ease of convenience and habit, it is evolving into a payments manager, managing loan instalments, subscriptions, utility bills, and insurance premiums. All this, without the customer even opening the app at times. No wonder that UPI AutoPay mandates surfaced repeatedly at the roundtable. Businesses which once relied on the National Automated Clearing House (NACH), or credit-card mandates, have started investing in rupee mandates or UPI mandates.
The next phase will increasingly demand a mandate that isn’t chained to a single payment gateway. NPCI is rolling out AutoPay interoperability, so a mandate can be ported across UPI apps and payment providers without the customer having to register again.
A 99.99% success rate is now the new industry table stakes; for a merchant, the value lies in recovering the 0.01% of transactions that fail at scale. Merchants would increasingly demand faster integration, clear success metrics, quick refunds, uptime.
What’s preventing UPI’s credit line acceleration?
Credit on UPI was meant to be the obvious next act. Banks have been allowed to offer credit lines through the payment app since 2023, placing borrowing inside an interface people already use every day. Yet the numbers suggest that almost nobody has made it work. Credit-line payments on UPI are estimated to have totalled only around ₹350 crore in July, largely through one bank and one payment app.Credit lines on UPI can currently be offered only by banks, including small finance banks, while non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) remain outside. The consequence is not merely regulatory; it shapes who feels the product is meant for them. The large banks, meanwhile, have little reason to make the shelf more crowded. A note of caution: opening the door to non-bank lenders will not be enough by itself. How the product is designed, priced and delivered will matter just as much.
The bigger debate is whether credit on UPI is really a payments product or a lending product. For someone already underwritten, it adds convenience; for someone new to credit, it does little on its own. Its closest cousins, overdraft and cash-credit facilities, are themselves poorly penetrated among small businesses. Even customers with pre-sanctioned bank limits rarely use them.
Consider the mason. He draws ₹1,000-2,000 to buy a couple of bags of cement, and that small line becomes his working capital for the month. Lenders are also using six months of a worker’s or sole proprietor’s UPI activity to underwrite short-term loans for people with no prior access to formal credit, something state-backed programmes, such as PM SVANidhi, had earlier struggled to achieve. As India remains largely a debit market, a credit line embedded in a familiar payment app could bring new users to credit in Tier 3 and Tier 4 cities.
Fraud central and how fintechs must respond
The emerging consensus is that the constantly evolving and burgeoning fraud underbelly, which has grown at the unprecedented pace of UPI itself, demands greater attention. A single firm investing in security would be able to safeguard only its users, while a weaker new entrant gets compromised and users across the ecosystem pay for it. Artificial intelligence (AI) has further lowered the skill needed to find vulnerabilities.No single company can win that game alone. It has to be part of a collective consensus and shared efforts. Whether it is network intelligence and shared data on buyer behaviour, the way data pooled across many online merchants can already separate high-risk from low-risk cash-on-delivery buyers. NPCI’s own National Common Mobility Card programme has implementations certified by an independent party before launch. And that can become a model for UPI. The The security burden also has to shift from individual apps to payment service providers, leaving fintechs free to focus on innovation.
With industry leaders sharing such diverse insights at the Mindgate roundtable discussion, the overarching consensus seemed to suggest that someone has to fund the rails, someone has to build on them, and someone has to protect them when things go wrong.
For merchants, the test will be simple: does the fee buy anything they can use, or does it just make accepting money more expensive? For TPAPs and smaller fintechs, it is whether a system built for scale can finally make room for them to earn, innovate and compete. For borrowers, it is whether credit can reach the mason buying cement, the worker in Telangana, or the customer in a Tier 3 town who has never held a credit card.
UPI’s first decade made digital payments commonplace. Its second will decide who pays for the system, who earns from it, who gets credit through it, and who is responsible when it fails.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.